Friday, July 28, 2006

Post-Christian Britain

There are now more black churchgoers in London than white and the black-led churches such as KICC are bursting at the seams.

Ruth Gledhill, The Times, 7/27/2006

What Are Academics For?

An article by Mary Beard, of Cambridge University, in the Times Online 7/18/2006

Thursday, July 27, 2006

A Byzantine Document in the News

The manuscript in question is a 13th century prayerbook that is also, as a palimpsest, the oldest surviving manuscript of Archimedes.

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5583668

I have to say that, as a Byzantinist, I find the dismissal of the Byzantine context of the manuscript somewhat annoying.

The manuscript is in the Walter's Art Museum in Baltimore (a truly wonderful place). It has its own website at http://www.archimedespalimpsest.org/

Trey in China

One of the links on the right of this page is to Treyopia. Trey is a former student of mine who is teaching in China. The blog is really an account of his experiences there. It's really good, and should inspire those who have not yet traveled to "get on yer bike."

After you get back, you forget all the diarrhea, people spitting on trains, fear of being so afr from home. After you get back, you look at the people around you and wonder how they get get by without knowing there is a world to see.

The Last Ottoman

Ertugrul Osman is the current head of the Ottoman dynasty. The Ottomans ruled much of the middle east from c.1299 until 1922. They were regarded with horror by muhc of Europe, but to an increasing number of people, the Ottoman period in the middle east looks increasingly benign. Compared to the disaster of ethnic and religious conflict it seems positively benificient.

It turns out the current heir lives in New York City (New York Times, 3/26/2006) in a Lexington Avenue apartment. And he has a Jewish landlord.

The world is an interesting place indeed.

The Israel-Hezbollah War: Who is to Blame?

In The Guardian 7/27/2006, Timothy Garton Ash argues that Europe created the mess.

In Slate 7/26/2006 Daniel Benjamin argues America is at fault.

I suppose it is just possible that both/or Israel and Hezbollah have some responsibility.

And Some People Think Jacksonville is a Small Town

"When Applebee's opened here, people really thought Jamestown was finally on the map," says Robert Carlson, president of the Farmers Union and a Jamestown resident.

Time 7/27/2006

Wednesday, July 26, 2006

History Questions 7/26/2006

This blog is linked to from the Internet History Sourcebooks Project. If you have come here with some question, ask it as a "reply to the this post (which will be reposted every few days).

Wikipedia on the 750th Anniversary of the US

..according to the The Onion

The entry also addresses several traditionally taboo subjects, such as the influence of LSD on the drafting of the Constitution and the role of funk-slaves in painting the White House black.

The Onion 7/26/2006

I love Wikipedia, but a friend tipped me off on this.

Gay Marriage today

There was a second consecutive state supreme court decision against same-sex marriage today (in Washington state), but this is a less a disaster than it might seem. Many years ago Andrew Sullivan argued that this policy would advance through a mix of methods, and in a patchwork pattern. He is turning out to be right. Court decisions certainly paved the way in both Canada and the US. Those court decisions have undercut any argument that gay marriage is destroying society: no such thing has happened as gay couples have proved to be just as boring (or exciting) as straight couples.

Legislatures now have some room to work - hence Connecticut created Civil Union laws, and California has come down in favor of equality for gay marriage. Now individual politicians running for state wide office are using the issue as an argument to vote for them.

"I think same sex marriage should be legal. I will propose a bill to permit that to be the case in the state of New York."

Elliott Spitzer, almost certainly next governor of New York State http://time.blogs.com/daily_dish/2006/07/Washington's_cou.html

Spitzer, almost certainly, will run for president at some date, but he is not hedging his bets in any way.

As long as it exists in only one state, gay marriage remains in some danger. Once you get eight or more states where it is recognized, then the game is over. My guess for the first eight states: Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, California, Rhode Island, Oregon and, perhaps, Illinois. Wht Illinois, even though half the state is in the South? Because that state was the first to legalize homosexual behaviour (in 1961), and because it contains a world city.

World cities have been at the forefront of celebrating gay people. And world cities enjoy being world cities. The more anti-gay legislation is seen as unclassy and small minded, the more it will be disputed.

[In the UK, all the rights of marriage have been extended to gay people via "civil partnerships." I guess Britain will probably continue to use this old fashioned language for longer than necessary, even as the population just uses "wed/married/hitched", and then all of a sudden in a burst of modernization will adopt the term "marriage" as a form of tidying up.

It is hard to express why this issue is so important. It is not really about hospital visits or social acceptance (many/most hospitals have accepted same-sex partners of patients for quite some time now), but of the impact of the creation of a widely know legal formualary for gay relationships on younger people who are just recognizing themselves. When you know that there is a state performed gay union rite, you will not ever feel as you grow up that you are alone. It is due to an obligation to those who will come after us that gay people, and not just activists, have come to see this issue as crucial.]

The Queen has to look like the Queen.


"There are all sorts of considerations about what she wears that the rest of us don't have to worry about," says Penny Junor, the royal biographer. "She can't wear skirts that are going to fly over her head if there is a gust of wind, or hats that are going to shield her face, because she has to be visible. Decorum is a big consideration, she could never have low-fronts, she always has to be model perfect."

Her choice of bright, pastel colours might not always be of the moment, but they enable fans and press cameras to pick her out in the midst of large crowds. Because the Queen has to look like the Queen.

A defense of Her Majesty's fashion sense in a very unlikely place, Scotland's newspaper The Scotsman, 7/26/2006

Tuesday, July 25, 2006

Shakespeare does the G8

Giorgio: But good Antonio, take we counsel now concerning the Levant.
My lord Annan, charged by the nations in their assembly to calm the noise of war,
Seeks only to separate the arms, thinking thereby to fulfil the task.
But the enmerded Moor, taking this peace for respite and repose,
By my vision, readies his galleys for renewed assault on the enrag’d Jew.

The Times, July 25th

"Enmerded Moor"?

Gay People to Blame for Hezbollah Attacks

As I've mentioned before, the business of opposing a planned Gay Pride march in Jerusalem is one of the few topics which generate widespread agreement between religious groups in that city, groups which are otherwise generally at each others' throats. The imams never wanted the march; both the Orthodox and the Catholic clergy didn't either; nor most of the rabbis. Indeed one rabbi saw the Hezbollah attacks on Israel as a direct consequence of the planned parade.

James Collard, The Times July 24

The "World Pride" festival was scheduled to take place in Jerusalem in August. All the religious groups opposed it.

Brits in America

To be honest, I think my whole mood, even my view of life struck the wrong note here. Americans cherish a self-image of themselves as casual, lively and free and the English as reserved, even stuck-up. But sometimes the opposite is true and I'd get in to trouble for swearing, for example, or making a frivolous remark about the task in hand ("well, it's only words and pictures!") to lighten the mood, none of which tends to go down well here. To use broad brush-strokes, I'd say that Americans are more serious, less flip; then again, they can seem more determined than Brits, less cynical. These are our different national virtues.

And with gay culture here, very often the mood of seriousness - and a readiness for anger which I found truly shocking - comes from entirely understandable sources. Gay America was hit harder by AIDS, for example, while the Religious Right is a serious opponent. In Britain, one senses that despite setbacks, gay people pushing for equality are pushing against a door which opens ever wider with every year. In America, there is an equally energetic, often more powerful lobby pushing back from the other side. So ever apparent step forward - like a State moving to endorse gay marriage (and gay marriage is a particularly sore subject in this city right now) results in a backlash, with a highly motivated, politically organised Christian right lobbying for constitutional changes or redress through higher courts.

James Collard, The Times, Jul 14 2006

I largely agree with his comments. British people think America is like Britain (and vice-versa). But it's not. America is a very foreign country. This is good in some ways (the relative lack of class consciousness, the divideness of government), but severely awful in others (the lack of vacation time, the avoidance of real class conflict, the willingness to deny government interference in life combined with allowing massive private enterprise control and intrusion).

Monday, July 24, 2006

It's getting hotter

The question of why there aren't viable alternative energy options (particularly when the electric car was not only more popular than the gasoline engine once upon a time but was also shown as recently as ten years ago to be a working technology) is raised subtly by An Inconvenient Truth. The rest of it--the pictures of glaciers shrinking into nothing, the graphs demonstrating the massive increase in greenhouse gasses in the last few decades--ties in cozily with the sudden hurricane-destruction of New Orleans and the evacuation of a lot of Pennsylvania due to fears of flooding. You're alarmed by it only if you don't think that, to crib from "The Daily Show", Adam and Eve rode a brontosaurus to church and, perhaps more divisively and to the point, that evolution is a theory and that two men who want to get married spells moral and spiritual Armageddon more neatly than does invading a Muslim country for their oil.

Film Freak: Review of An Inconvenient Truth.

Do it like Zidane

ZIDANE a new way to solve problems.. do it like zidane...

OK,I wrote during the World Cup, so I can cite this clip.

YouTube is about to jump the shark.

Dance - Going Viral?

I love this. Evolution of Dance

Takes me right back to Studio 54.

The War in the Levant

In my opinion, this is becoming PR disaster for Israel.

The Lebanese do not look like raving maniacs, and I don't think Israel has had a war before where the opposing country comes over so well. Lebanon is not like other Arab countries. The Lebanese do not look like women-oppressing Saudis, or enraged barbaric Palestinians, or a raving Shi'te mob. They look like us: they look like people in Miami living under shelling. Hell, many of them are Christian, perhaps 40%.

Some IM correspondents have asked me about my opinion. Here it is.

I support Israel. I think both the West and the Islamic World owe Jews an immense apology for the way (worse in the West) both civilizations treated Jews. I think anti-Semitism in the Arab world is disgusting. And I think, as a gay man, Israel is the only country in the Middle East (outside Turkey) I could live in. And if it comes down to it, I am on the Israeli side.

But, I will not count an Arab life (Chistian or Muslim) as less than a Jewish or "American" life.

I have indeed noticed that there is a helluva lot of PR going around me. [We have 350+ dead on both sides after 12 days. Damned, more people have died from driving accidents in Israel in this period. More people died in the first 30 seconds of the Somme in 1916.]

This is a skirmish in the wider scheme of things. I think people suggesting the thesis that were are beginning WWIII have jumped the shark. I could be wrong, but...(See if I am wrong).

  • As of 7/24/2006 WWIII is not on the the radar. Israel has had an effect on Hezbollah, and will exercise a suppressive effect via land forces in the next 4 days. It has perhaps fivemore days to do this.

  • Condeleeza Rice's presence from Sunday in the he middle east will mean a smaller war and growing pressure because the western media are refusing to reduce the Lebanese people to the animality. [I could be very wrong here.] Many of us have, as well as Jewish, Lebanese friends and colleagues.

  • Both sides seem to have miscalculated to a massive extent. Hezbollah did not expect Israel to fight back (as it has a right to do); but Israel did not realize the impact it is making in the US with continual raids on a modern city.

    [And, since we are all racist, the world has just ignored Darfur, AND the coming Somali-Ethiopian War, AND the Tsunami in Java.]
  • Conservatives and Me

    It's odd but true that, since I moved to the US South, most of my best friends, and in recent years, greatest supporters, are self-labeled "conservatives."

    I find many of the people who position themselves on the "left" to be either rabid or incoherent. Indeed for a British Democratic Socialist, modern US progressives are hard to deal with: we often share political positions, but a "left" without the working class is very odd.

    The problem is, as was shown when I made an overly emotional post on gay marriage, is that in a real way there are some basic issues where it's hard for me to comprehend how someone can be friendly with me, but still see me as some kind of inferior being, and where the only kind of relationships I could form that would bring happiness, are seen as evil.

    On the other hand, I suppose that with those conservatives who befriend me (suddenly I sound like a wet puppy), homosexuality is not a primary issue. They are pissed off at what they see as a nanny state, and, in economic terms, focus on the virtues of self-reliance and oppose a dependency culture. (I have met very few people, of any group, who think the War on Drugs makes any sense. Even as they [and I] acknowledge what ruin drugs can bring on individuals.)

    I suppose that this will remain a conundrum.

    WKCR in New York : Homosexuality in History

    I was interviewed today by Shoshana Schwartz of WKCR (Columbia University Radio) in New York. The subject was attituded to homosexuality in Ancient Greece, in comparison with other ancient cultures and modern culture.

    The interview will air as a segment of a program called Late City Edition, and will first air on Tuesday 25th July between 9 and 9:30pm.

    On the air, if you are in the New York area, the frequency is 89.9 FM. You can listen on the internet at www.wkcr.org.

    UPDATE: the interview air on July 25th for around 15 minutes. The interviewer had somewhat odd voice (a bit like Diane Rehm on NPR). The interview should be archived at www.wkcr.org under archives>news>Late City Edition 7/25/2006, but it's not there yet.

    God, guns, and gays


    See also Rudy Giuliani in Drag Smooching Donald Trump at YouTube.

    Newsweek'’s Eleanor Clift had plenty of company when she contemplated Hurricane Katrina'’s devastation and asked, "“Where is Rudy Giuliani when we need him?" In the political-leadership sweepstakes, Giuliani is A-number-one, top of the list, king of the hill. But Sinatra'’s catchy claim is turned on its head in the presidential sweepstakes: When it comes to winning over GOP primary voters, if you can make it in New York, you can't make it anywhere else.

    God, guns, and gays. An interesting article by Kate O'Beirne in the National Review on why Rudy Giuliani cannot get the Republican nomination for President.

    It does soometimes look as if political conservatism (as opposed to ideological conservatism) has come down to these issues among many American men. I think Giuliani would be an awful president, and articles written at the time of his New York mayoral runs in the New Yorker about his past would almost certainly sink him.

    The National Review highlights the article on its cover with a picture of Rudy Giuliani dressed up as Marilyn Monroe. This image was quite well known in New York. It was from a fundraising party in which Giuliani ordered all his top staff to cross dress, and then himself dressed as Marilyn, and sang "Happy Birthday, Mr. President." At the time, Drag bars in New York put "Thank You Mr Mayor" posters in their windows.

    But O'Beirne is an old bird. I wonder if all this will make any difference. The "god, guns, and gays" issue seem to me to be as much about male self image than anything else. Many men simply use these issues as markers for the WIMP (Woefully I Inadequate Male Person) issue. But, whatever his faults, and no matter how much you dislike him, noone could regard Giliani as a WIMP.

    After all, it takes a strong man to wear a dress.

    {update: Andrew Sullivan discusses the New Republics covere here

    Sunday, July 23, 2006

    Looks Like a New Saint's Cult to Me

    My dissertation was, in part, an exploration of the "contestation" that took place during the creation of new saints.

    Follow this report on "Fr. Mark" of the Punjab: BBC, 23 July 2006.

    That he "fought" Church leaders is a trope of sanctity.

    Friday, July 21, 2006

    Shi'ism and the News

    Rememember Nixon!

    That's my motto in watching news coverage of any event. The Daily Telegraph is, by far, the most Conservative British newspaper. It is also very pro-Israel. But the British upper-middle class British values a much wider divergence of opinion than exists in the US. That is where to look for angles you may not have thought of.

    Here is an very informative view on the Shia-Sunni conflict from today's Telegraph.

    Rats....

    Exiled radical Islamic preacher Omar Bakri was turned away from a Royal Navy ship evacuating Britons from war-torn Beirut, it emerged today.
    The Muslim cleric, who left Britain for Lebanon abruptly in August last year, tried to board the British ship yesterday. He also claimed he had written to the British embassy asking to be allowed to back on "humanitarian grounds".

    The Guardian, today.

    There is a Yiddish word for what this guy has: Chutzpah. [Defined by example by Leo Rosten in The Joys of Yiddish. A man kills both his parents: he pleads to the judge for mercy on the grounds he is an orphan.]

    This does not seem the time....

    ...for Israel to be commemorating a famous terrorist act against the British Mandate government in Palestine. Sixty years ago the Irgun Zvi Leumi blew up a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem. 91 people were killed. Now there is a celebration.

    At a time when, unlike French or Russian leader, Britain's Prime Minister is vocally supporting Israel, this seems a little strange.

    Oh My G-d

    This is what America is watching!

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=UygWaEDfKJ8

    Don't be upset. Brits made "Run Rabbit, Run, Run, Run" a hit in WW II.

    Update:

    At Slate

    Thursday, July 20, 2006

    The War Today

    It was very odd today. I was worring like crazy [C-R-A-Z-Y] about being ill, but my doctor is of Lebanese Christian origin.

    When I went in, and said how upset I was very upset about what was going on. He seemed surprised that any of his patients would even care (or know, I suppose, this being Jacksonville FL and not Dearborn MI). It turns out all his family is in Lebanon, although (thankfully), mostly in the north.

    I, of course, like Israel, but find myself hopeless before men of violence: I could imagine being angry on both sides. I simply cannot imagine myself firing a weapon to kill children.

    I hope, if I am ever presented with the choice, that I cut my own throat.

    What Would Jesus Do? Can anyone imagine him firing a Kassem rocket into Israel? Or dropping a bomb on South Beirut?

    What would you do?

    The "Iranian Picture"


    Rarely is the hatred of homosexuals, which flourishes within many of the world's fundamentalist religions, seen so starkly. If the Old Testament, a font of three of the world's major faiths, is the inerrant Word of God, then why should these images trouble you? For God, in Leviticus, says that the killing of homosexuals is justice and pleasing to him.

    But if the images trouble the conscience nonetheless, then the viewer finds himself in exactly the position of every gay person who has wrestled with traditional morality and its often harsh absolutes. You find within yourself a moral consciousness that is wider than the wellspring of ancient religion. It is a dizzying sensation of liberation, and its power pulses through every line written by Walt Whitman. But it is, for many, a terrifying thought, and so images are suppressed. And the wasted lives of two young men are ignored by all except those who, through the strange ether of the Internet, feel a powerful kinship with them.


    WashPost

    Protests against Iranian Attacks on Gays

    The Iranian regime is the among the most homophobic in the world. In the past day or so, Lesbians, Gays, Bisexual, TG people, and associated queers have organized protests around the world in connection with the judical murder of two gay Iranian teenagers a on July 19 2005.

    Andrew Sullivan is keeping tabs on this, as is an old acquaintance of mine, Michael Petrelis.

    See also a Washington Post article [ Pictures From An Execution Come Into Focus ] on these protests, and the state murder of these guys.

    Excerpt

    Perhaps the saddest thing about these pictures is that no major news organization outside Iran has tracked down what really happened. The final indignity of these boys' short lives was that they didn't matter enough to spark a serious investigation. And yet, even with the particular facts of the alleged crimes in dispute, the images have haunted gay people in the West and become part of a larger debate about the political alignment of gay rights groups. Should Western activists engage with gay rights issues across cultural and religious borders? And do they risk being dragged into a crude anti-Islamic fervor popular among some fundamentalist Christians (who are no friends to gay people) and right-wing political groups?

    Rob Anderson, 23, organized the Dupont Circle protest of about 40 people. He is a researcher and reporter for the New Republic, and he describes himself as part of a "network of lefty friends" who have no interest in the idea of war with Iran. But when the images of the hangings went up last year on the Internet, he printed them out and put them up near his desk. He says that all the friends he's shown the pictures to have had "a shift in consciousness," a realization that they live sheltered lives, that evil exists in the world and that despite the vast cultural difference between Iran and the United States, there have to be moral absolutes. And killing children for homosexuality is one thing that is absolutely wrong.

    Wednesday, July 19, 2006

    News Analysis of the Current Conflict

    Currant news commentators seem to be on the money about the basic Sunni vs Shia conflict going on in the Middle East. I'm a little uneasy though.

    There is real reason for taking Sunni-Shia conflict seriously. It has created long lasting religious war frequently in the past. In fact, even beyond the early divisions, there have been a number of periods of intense Sunni-Shia conflict.

  • By Sunni Muslims (especially the Seljuk Turks) against the Fatamid Caliphate (10th-12th centuries in Egypt). The descendants of the Fatamid Caliphate are "Sevener" of Ismaili Shia (the Aga Khan is the current leader of the group). The Druze also seem to be descendants of the Fatamids, but of a heretical group which proclaimed the Fatamid Caliph Hakim as God. (Hakim, by the way was responsible for the destruction of the Holy Sepulcher in the early 11th century, and event later used in Crusader propaganda).
  • Between the Ottoman Turks and the Safavid dynasty (which was Turkish, but ruled in Iran from the 16th to 18th century). This last one was fought explicitly by the Ottomans as a religious war, and indeed only Armenians were allowed to travel between the two empires (the border was roughly that of modern Iran).
  • There is continual religious violence between Shia and Sunni in Pakistan (remember India/Pakistan/Bangladesh contain around half the world's Muslims)
  • Iran is run by Twelver Shia (i.e. they believe in the descent of infallible Imams up until the 12th Imam, who is now in hiding, but who speaks through the Shia Ulema [religious judges - more like Orthodox rabbis than Catholic priests]). They account for around 80% of world Shia, and are also the dominant group in Iraq. Hezbollah is a Twelver group.

    One can see why Sunni Muslims might be worried.

    But there are problems with a merely religious analysis of what is going on.

  • Syria is mostly Sunni, but the Assad dynasty belongs to a group called the Alawites, who are not regarded as Muslims by most other Muslims, either Twelvers or Sunnis. The Alawites are defined by the others as extremists because they seem to have regarded 'Ali as a kind of incarnation of God. (This is a little unsure because most Alawites don't know the tenets of the faith: like the Druze these doctrines are kept as esoteric knowledge by a small group of older males.) There is no real reason for the Shia in Iran to regard the Alawites as allies.
  • In Hama/Homs in 1982, Bashir's father killed around 20,000 members of the very distinctly Sunni Muslim Brotherhood (the number includes bystanders) when the rose against his secularist Ba'ath Party (founded jointly by an Eastern Orthodox and a Sunni).

    The odd things here are.

  • Why is Syria supporting Hezbollah, when, as Twelvers, they are not in line with most of the Syrian population?
  • Why is Syria supporting HAMAS. HAMAS (the acronym comes from "Islamic Salvation Front) is simply the Palestinian branch of the Muslim Brotherhood (the same group that the Assads' massacre in 1982.

    I have no conclusions here. Merely that the analysis going on right now seems simplistic. Most commentators seem to assume there is just "Islamic radicalism" with understanding the vast difference between Sunnis and Shia. And even those who understand that do not seem to grasp that Syria is a Sunni country with a minority leadership whose sect is not considered Muslim by either Sunni or Shia ulema.

    UPDATE:

    Andrew Sullivan points to a Slate magazine article on this topic.
  • Bulls and Cows

    To cow (v. intrans.) or the act of cowing:

    To list data (or perform operations) without awareness of, or comment upon, the contexts, frames of reference, or points of observation which determine the origin, nature, and meaning of the data *(or procedures). To write on the assumption that "a fact is a fact." To present evidence of hard work as a substitute for understanding, without any intent to deceive.

    To bull (v. intrans.) or the act of bulling:

    To discourse upon the contexts, frames of reference and points of observation which would determine the origin, nature, and meaning of data if one had any. To present evidence of an understanding of form in the hope that the reader may be deceived into supposing a familiarity with content.


    Examsmanship and the Liberal Arts

    This is great!

    This link was posted on the Mediev-l list in response to the "Defining History" documents. If you understand it you can do great history, if not, you can't. It's as simple as that.

    Tuesday, July 18, 2006

    Vader Sessions

    Darth at Youtube

    Life after Forty

    anyone who says that life begins at forty is full of crap! As people get older their bodies begin to decay. They get sick. They forget things. What's good about that?

    Bette Davis

    Unclaimed Territory

    Interesting comments (linked to by Andrew Sullivan)on right wing blogs -
    Unclaimed Territory - by Glenn Greenwald: The thug and intimidation tactics of the Far Right go mainstream

    Way to Go, Fox News!

    I never thought I'd write that line!

    This video is going viral

    Youtube: Fox Anchor vs. Westboro Baptist Church

    I never really liked Julie Banderas before. In some respects this may be the best fight since Krystal vs. Alexis on Dynasty.

    Defining History 2

    Having read the law referred to below, it strikes me less as a right wing plot, and more like student wish-fulfillment.

    No matter how many times you try to teach/show students that history is a matter of investigation (Greek: 'istoria), narrative (French, etc.: histoire), and interpretation, many of the dear little ones often seem to want to be bored (in what they consider a useless required subject). They really would prefer a list of facts they could just remember.

    I was at a store the other day, talking to a guy, and I mentioned (when he asked why I was in the US) that I had come to study for a doctorate in history. He then asked what use was that unless I wanted to teach? I asked him in return what use it was learning how to plumb unless he wanted to be a plumber?

    He was gob-smacked, as we would say in Manchester.

    [of course plumbers make more.]

    Defining History

    as part of an education bill signed into law by Gov. Jeb Bush, Florida has declared that “American history shall be viewed as factual, not as constructed.”

    Robert Jensen, workingforchange.com 07.17.06: "Florida’s fear of history: New law undermines critical thinking."

    This is quite incredible. Thanks to James.

    UPDATE: I had been more than a little surprised by the story above. But it seems to be be quite legitimate.

    See
  • Tampa Tribune
  • History News Network
  • LA Times
  • Daily Kos

    The Bill itself is at http://election.dos.state.fl.us/laws/06laws/ch_2006-074.pdf
  • Talk About Bad Timing

    Possibly the worst timed club opening in recent history:
    Paddy Cochrane, the nephew of Sursock doyenne Lady Cochrane, celebrated the opening of his new nightlife venue in Gemmayzeh on Friday night. Gauche Caviar - so named in a tongue-in-cheek reference to the first wave of reveling gentrifiers who paved the way for this quaintly residential and traditional neighborhood to become Beirut's latest hipster enclave - is located on Gemmayzeh's main drag, Gouraud Street. Unlike most of the nearby bars, cafes, restaurants and clubs, Gauche Caviar is notably spacious, thanks in no small part to a winning design by architect Mazen Khatib. The launch party welcomed a roster of high-profile guests.

    Daily Star, Beirut, July 12

    Thursday, July 13, 2006

    The War in the Middle East

    [Updated]

    We are now facing a major regional conflict in the middle east.

    Ignore the New York Times, Washington Post, or BBC.

    For Lebanon see the Daily Star

    For Israel, see Ha'aretz

    Commentators in the press, from the White House and academia seem not to know who differences between Sunni and Shia, nor that there are different types of Shia. I have seen almost no-one refer to the very large Christian communitues in the country (the majority being an Eastern Church (the Maronites) in communion with Rome. Commentary in the British and the American Press seems to be describing different wars. And all the commentators from the areas affected are spinning like crazy.

    Meantime, as usual, every other crisis in the world gets ignored. Today, genocide continues in Dafur, there was another Tsunami in Indonesia, and something weird is happening in North Korea - it's all enough to make one despair.

    Pray for peace.

    Another Brick in the Graveyard

    This summary is not available. Please click here to view the post.

    Simple, Shallow, and Banal

    On the issue of anonymous blog posters, there is an interesting discussion going on over at an article by Timothy Garton Ash at the Guardian. This comment (by Nagajchaos) was interesting:

    Bad ideas in your last paragraph: anonymity is not the issue. The issue is that the Blogosphere has revealed a central truth we educators have known for years. Most people are simple, shallow, banal, and relatively inarticulate. It takes a rare degree of perception, insight and understanding to construct a decent argument. That's why there are so few of them. Naming the writers will not improve the quality of their arguments. That the vicious and stupid are sometimes encouraged to be nasty by their anonymity is unfortunate, but naming them will not make them go away. Not any more. The best thing to do is to respond well to those who respond well.


    More at the article

    Textbooks and Authors

    From today's New York Times

    This is how the 2005 edition of "A History of the United States," a high school history textbook by the Pulitzer Prize-winning historian Daniel J. Boorstin and Brooks Mather Kelley, relates the cataclysmic attacks of 9/11 for a new generation of young adults:

    "In New York City, the impact of the fully fueled jets caused the twin towers to burst into flames. The fires led to the catastrophic collapse of both 110-story buildings as well as other buildings in the area. The numbers of people missing and presumed dead after this assault was estimated to be 2,750."

    The language is virtually identical to that in the 2005 edition of another textbook, "America: Pathways to the Present," by different authors. The books use substantially identical language to cover other subjects as well, including the disputed presidential election of 2000, the Persian Gulf war, the war in Afghanistan and the creation of the Department of Homeland Security .

    Just how similar passages showed up in two books is a tale of how the largely obscure $4 billion a year world of elementary and high school textbook publishing often works, for these passages were not written by the named authors but by one or more uncredited writers. And while it is rare that the same language is used in different books, it is common for noted scholars to give their names to elementary and high school texts, lending prestige and marketing power, while lesser known writers have a hand in the books and their frequent revisions.

    As editions pass, the names on the spine of a book may have only a distant or dated relation to the words between the covers, diluted with each successive edition, people in the industry, and even authors, say.

    [more at the article

    The Time's article discusses something that almost never reaches the general public - the problems of the "new edition" cycle of college textbooks. I have been involved in these and I am quite sure that many of the writers are dedicated and careful. More than that texts (even in medieval history) do need to change as new information comes to light, and perhaps more importantly as the histories of hitherto disregarded people are incorporated. [George Ostrogorsky's History of the Byzantine State, in many respects admirable, manages to avoid mention of any non-imperial woman in its index.]

    But the three-year new edition cycle of some books is driven by another cause: the efforts of publishers to avoid loosing sales by students reselling books after a course. Perhaps the best solution would be for students to simply keep their textbooks - after all, if they are interesting enough, the books you buy in college should form the basis for a future library.

    Wednesday, July 12, 2006

    Torture is not American



    If you are American, do you believe that this man would agree to crushing the testicles of a captured enemies' children, or to threatening a capitive (however evil) with castrating his son?

    Bush agreed to to it. [See Andrew Sullivan's blog for the most impassioned discussion on this issue - is it just Brits who are so upset at this?]

    For God's sake, you people among whom I have lived for twenty years but still do not understand, can you live up to being American? Can you be a light for the nations? A City set on a Hill?

    Because if you can't, you're not American.

    Let Canada take the title: it deserves it if you choose to become some oppressive empire with no rule of law except that of one one rather intellectually limited Yankee (even if he claims to be a Texan).

    To be Free, Celebrate

    From Andrew Sullivan

    if you're a gay person who hasn't talked to a co-worker or family member about why marriage matters, then you're not part of this movement. Stop relying on judges or political lobbies - and fight the fight yourself: person by person, again and again and again. Never duck an opportunity to engage; never let a dumb argument go unchallenged; never be intimidated by those wanting you to be silent or talk about something else. In the immortal words of Quentin Crisp:


    It is not the simple statement of facts that ushers in freedom; it is the constant repetition of them that has this liberating effect. Tolerance is the result not of enlightenment, but of boredom.


    By the way, I am not interested in the acceptance or toleration of gay people. I am interested in celebrating us.

    Many of you who read this are my friends, do you really I would be better if I where straight? God, I may be a bad gay person, but I would be such an asshole as a straight person.

    Tuesday, July 11, 2006

    Muslims and Catholics as Terrorists

    I was discussing earlier with a friend the current atrocity in Bombay. He asked if there was an underlying problem with Islam.

    My thoughts

    I think Muslims will always think they are superior, just as will Catholics, Jews, and Southern Baptists. Religions are about truth systems, and obviously people of a given religion will think they are superior.

    What is essential is to realize that these killers represent neither the mainstream nor best of "The Religion of Being at Peace with God and Neighbour" (i.e. Islam). Islam, in its holy texts (Qur'an and Hadith), main law schools, and main historical manifestations (Abbasid Baghdad, Ayyubbid Cairo, Ottoman Istanbul, Mughal India) has taught and practiced respect of life, protection of the poor and orphans, and insisted on seeing all people as children of God.

    Some people seem to be judging Muslims now, as if Rwanda (where all were Catholic) represented Catholicism.

    Think about that: the entire history of Catholicism being captured by those Tutu priests who participated in genocide. That would not be fair to Catholicism, and we are not fair to Islam to associate it with maniacs.

    How to Be Happy

    Life has been tough in the past two years, but I have recently discovered two perfectly legal ways to "get happy". One is a kind of forced meditation, the other is opening up to ones' own life experience.

    1. Simply to sit down and force yourself to remember happy days. I mean specific days, the ones which make life worth living (My Mother hugging me and telling me she would always love me as her son, gay or not; lying one night with he who still remains the love of my live and thanking God; seeing the sun rise over the Dead Sea as I climbed Masada with a group of incandescent UNF students,....There are so many more.) Try it when you are depressed.

    2. The other came about, rather oddly, when I was bored in a Lakeland Motel recently. I began to read Job in the Gideons's Bible there (which I stole - I hope that's OK). Lo and behold, I have not actualy tried to read the King James version for 30 years. But, to try to put this humbly, my reading ability has improved a lot since I was 15. The translation is sheer, almost overwhelming, poetry.

    Bobby Charlton and Zidane


    The Zidane Story

    It has probably amazed a number of my friends how involved I have been with the world cup. In an earlier post I addressed why it is hard for a very openly gay guy to admit liking football - the ritual, the continuous flow of the game, the cute guys....

    I was born in Manchester in 1960. There will only ever be one greatest footballer for me - Bobby Charlton. But Zidane is number two, and Zidane remains number two for me, even after the World Cup incident. The Italian called his mother an Arab terrorist and Zidane lost his cool. He lost his cool defending the honor of his mother.

    That is no reason not to admire the man who has most helped France get over its racism to Franco-Algerians, and who in all normal encounters is the model of a gentleman.

    Vive Zidane! [If you read French, Le Monde has the most extensive coverage.]

    Bombings in India

    Something really bad has just happened in India - at least seven bombings of commuter trains.

    There is a really probability of massive attacks on Muslim populations in India if these turn out to be Jihadist related. I fact I predict such conflicts unless some miracle happens - India needs a political leader now as at no other time.

    This is a new development in terrorism - the deliberate effort to create mass communal conflict by a small group. In Northern Ireland the IRA never attacked Protestant religious institutions (only British/Government ones) and the Protestant UVF and the Orange Order never attacked a Catholic Church.

    It's a mistake to think that terrorism is always the same. In the early days or terrorism (think of groups like the Irgun Zvi Leumi and its Arab equivalents) they used to think of legitimate targets and and aimed to induce terror among the living not death as an end ititself. [IZL tried to scare Arabs out of Eretz Yisrael/Palestine, the Arabs did the same thing.]

    History always contextualizes terrorism. Catholics and Protestants in Ireland fought over history, but they did not systematically seek to deny the history of the others. In both the Balkans and Israel, by contrast there has been for almost a hundred years now an efforst to write opponents out of history.

    Neither Greek nor Israeli tour guides, for example, ever credit 500 years of Ottoman history. Israel and the Turkish government do, to their credit, preserve the monuments of of all the cultures that have flourished in their territories, although they mount official "stories" which leave much out. In Israel, Masada is spectacular (and a symbol of Jewish resistance), but Sepphoris, where the Jews gave in to Roman forces, survived, and went on to create Talmudic Judaism, is almost never shown to tourists. Because its lesson - Jews often flourished by submitting to greater military might - but the managed to create incredible learning and literature, does not fit with Israel's guiding myth.

    Outside Israel and Turkey, both of which have very responsible archeological ministries, it has become common in the eastern Mediterranean to destroy the evidence of "opposing cultures." [In the Irish context this would be as if the Republic of Ireland had systematically destroyed all the great cathedrals of Ireland, which belong to the (Anglican) Church of Ireland rather to than the Roman Catholic majority. [However badly you might thing of Dev (De Valera), it's impossible to imagine him ever even thinking of such a thing.]

    In Serbia, EVERY mosque is destroyed, In Kosovo, priceless centers of Serbian history have been either destroyed or saved only with massive effort. In Athens, all mosques have had their minarets cut off (who says Freudianism is wrong?), and in Salonica, which did not have a Christian majority until the Nazis killed the Jews, only one mosque with a minaret survives. Going there today, you would scarcely know, as you visit the "Aristotle University" that you are in fact walking on one of the largest Sephardic Jewish cemeteries ever known, nor that the MAIN language of the city until the 1940s was Judeo-Spanish (Ladino or Judezmo.)

    Every terrorism is culture based.

    The question is, how can we cure deviant cultures.

    Is that politically incorrect? To talk of "deviant cultures"? Here I take my stand with St. Thomas Aquinas. He argued that if a culture arose in which, for example, rape and infanticide were norms, the entire culture must be considered deviant. There are certainly varieties of allowed human cultural norms. But, the great saint insisted there are natural laws that no agreement between members of a culture can abrogate.

    In effect the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (thanks to the efforts of that great Lesbian Eleanor Roosevelt) is an attempt to encode St. Thomas' insight into international law.

    And this is how we do it - we must all agree that, even if it takes decades, any promoter, doer, cooperator, in mass death, genocide, or torture will NEVER be able to rest in peace.

    That certainly includes current Islamic terrorists. But others need to know the law will never give up on them. Pinochet was brought to trial; we need to bring more and more such men/women to trial so that every killing bastard knows that the world will never give up going after them.

    And that includes any American official who has betrayed his/her country's most siesmic claim - "all men are created equal with certain inalienable rights". They too must face the Court of Humanity. And gaol if necessary.

    Monday, July 10, 2006

    Christian Sex Toys

    Now I can see why Christians should be interested in TEXT TOYS (concordances etc.) but this website on "Intimacy Products for Married Couples" [thanks WM] goes one step step further. Basically it uses the Song of Songs to justify selling dildos and clitoral stimulators!

    The twenty-second book of the Bible is Song of Solomon. We believe that God intended that such love, as spoken of in Song of Solomon, be a beautiful and normal part of marital life. Unfortunately this gift from God has been grossly distorted and abused by both ancient and modern people. Book22 is offering quality products to enhance the intimate life of God's children. Our hope is that our products will serve as intimacy enhancers for your marriage.


    http://www.book22.com/merchant2/

    Intermittent Posting

    Posting has been intermittent for the past few days since I am facing a dodgy internet connection. Plus it has been depressing watching all the wrong teams win in the World Cup.

    I'll be back to normal soon.