Perspectives from an English Historian who just happens to be Gay, Catholic, and a Democratic Socialist. Now back in the UK after 20 years of living in the United States. The Blog is eclectic in covering all these sides of my Life. Follow on Twitter at PaulBHalsall
Friday, May 01, 2009
Two Songs for May Day
The Red Flag [Wikipedia here]
The workers' flag is deepest red,
It shrouded oft our martyred dead;
And ere their limbs grew stiff and cold
Their life-blood dyed its every fold.
CHORUS:
Then raise the scarlet standard high;
Beneath its folds we'll live and die,
Though cowards flinch and traitors sneer,
We'll keep the red flag flying here.
The Internationale [Wikipedia here]
Arise ye starvelings [or workers] from your slumbers
Arise ye criminals of want
For reason in revolt now thunders
and at last ends the age of cant.
Now away with all your superstitions
Servile masses arise, arise!
We'll change forthwith [or henceforth] the old conditions
And spurn the dust to win the prize.
CHORUS
Then come comrades rally
And the last fight let us face
The Internationale
Unites the human race. (repeat).
Thursday, April 30, 2009
Ten Best Gay Disco Songs
For May Day Weekend
[This is my Gay Disco version. Gay Disco had almost no contact with Straight Disco.]
Not in order:
1. "Gloria" Laura Branigan Live
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AG9OV1efasQ
2 Thelma Houston-Dont Leave me this way
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elIVoXUJ4V4
or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2P4z7t8bmsc
3. Hazell Dean - Searchin' - Top of the Pops 1984
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4bAt2wZXsU
4. I Feel Love - Donna Summer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8TBmeK9Abg
5. Donna Summer McArthur Park
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xaZim6ybvdA
6. DIVINE - You Think You're A Man
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IiIJOB0GLW4
7. SYLVESTER-DO YOU WANNA FUNK (remix)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sKstAXq2hh8
8. Lime - Guilty (1983)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pu1kAQpeI1E
9. Miquel Brown - So Many Men So Little Time
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_MiRWo4Myw
10. THE WEATHER GIRLS - IT'S RAINING MEN
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXudUM0vKSc
11. I will survive - Gloria Gaynor
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBR2G-iI3-I
12. Nipple 2 the bottle Grace Jones
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fs9kzmzHgmQ
Updated: November 2009 (to replace bad links)
[This is my Gay Disco version. Gay Disco had almost no contact with Straight Disco.]
Not in order:
1. "Gloria" Laura Branigan Live
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AG9OV1efasQ
2 Thelma Houston-Dont Leave me this way
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=elIVoXUJ4V4
or http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2P4z7t8bmsc
3. Hazell Dean - Searchin' - Top of the Pops 1984
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4bAt2wZXsU
4. I Feel Love - Donna Summer
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k8TBmeK9Abg
5. Donna Summer McArthur Park
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xaZim6ybvdA
6. DIVINE - You Think You're A Man
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IiIJOB0GLW4
7. SYLVESTER-DO YOU WANNA FUNK (remix)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sKstAXq2hh8
8. Lime - Guilty (1983)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pu1kAQpeI1E
9. Miquel Brown - So Many Men So Little Time
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_MiRWo4Myw
10. THE WEATHER GIRLS - IT'S RAINING MEN
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SXudUM0vKSc
11. I will survive - Gloria Gaynor
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZBR2G-iI3-I
12. Nipple 2 the bottle Grace Jones
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fs9kzmzHgmQ
Updated: November 2009 (to replace bad links)
The Seventh Seal?

Kenneth R Miller: Seals, evolution, and the real 'missing link' | Comment is free | guardian.co.uk
We found another 'missing link' this month. Or, to be more precise, a team of Canadian and American scientists found a missing link between modern seals and their land-dwelling ancestors. A report in this week's Nature magazine described fossils of an extinct land-dwelling animal, now called Puijila darwini, discovered in the Canadian arctic. Its remarkable skeletal structure provides a spectacular demonstration of how evolution modified the limbs of a land-dwelling animal to produce the flippers of modern seals and sea lions.
I am sure evolution is true as science, but I don't like it. It makes the physical world evil.
There really should be a modernization of Zoroastrian (or other) dualism that accepts the reality of the physical world, but which, like the squire in The Seventh Seal, says to nature, " I yield, but I do not submit."
Screw Prohibition!
Wine may help men outlive teetotallers | Society | The Guardian
'Long-term wine consumers had about five years longer life expectancy at age 50 compared with non-alcohol users. Of these five years, about two years can be attributed to an effect of alcohol intake. The remaining three years can be attributed to an effect of wine consumption.'
Britain's vibrator capital revealed
Britain's vibrator capital revealed | Metro.co.uk
It makes being "sent to Coventry" a very different prospect.
[American readers: this is impossible to explain.]
Coventry is the vibrator capital of Britain - according to a sex survey released today.
It makes being "sent to Coventry" a very different prospect.
[American readers: this is impossible to explain.]
The Drumbeat: An Upcoming Israeli Strike on Iran
Iain Dale's Diary: UK Banks Banning Iranian Customers?
I heard something interesting tonight while dining with friends. I haven't got the time today to follow this up, but a financial journalist might wish to do so. I was told that America banks are withdrawing all facilities from Iranian customers, and unilaterally closing their accounts with no prior consultation. But more to the point, British banks have started to do the same. One Iranian national, who has been a customer of the Royal Bank of Scotland for thirty years, was told his account was being closed. There was no explanation beyond him being told that it was now bank policy to withdraw all banking facilities from Iranian related accounts. This is, I am told, also happening in other UK banks. And it's being dictated by the US government - or so it is alleged.
Gordon Brown and Decency
Ruth Gledhill - Times Online - WBLG: Brown to honour 'heroes of the Holocaust'
I think the problem with Gordon Brown is that, although he moves like Iago as a politician, he is a fundamentally decent and educated man who sees life within a moral compass. Perhaps more so than Blair, and I think more so than Cameron or Clegg. (Among the Tories, I would cite David Davies and Anne Widdecombe as among those who are concerned with what is right as much as what is politic).
The problem is he is just an awful Prime Minister. It's a real tragedy.
Btw. Anyone can make missteps on the Holocaust - see this report in Haaretz on a problem for Yad Veshem.
Gordon Brown, on a visit to Auschwitz today, has revealed that he will tomorrow in the House of Commons announce a new award for British heroes of the Holocaust.
Last week was the Jewish Yom Ha'Shoah commemoration, which marks the religious commemoration of the Holocaust. Research that will be done annually for this day was published for the first time this year and showed the extent to which criticism of Israel can be a cover for anti-Semitism, even when that criticism is legitimate.
Gordon Brown has long wanted to visit Auschwitz. His father, a minister in the Presbyterian Church of Scotland, belonged to a church group which supported the foundation of the state of Israel.
I think the problem with Gordon Brown is that, although he moves like Iago as a politician, he is a fundamentally decent and educated man who sees life within a moral compass. Perhaps more so than Blair, and I think more so than Cameron or Clegg. (Among the Tories, I would cite David Davies and Anne Widdecombe as among those who are concerned with what is right as much as what is politic).
The problem is he is just an awful Prime Minister. It's a real tragedy.
Btw. Anyone can make missteps on the Holocaust - see this report in Haaretz on a problem for Yad Veshem.
What will Obama do about Israel?
ANALYSIS / Netanyahu will have to work to restore U.S.-Israel ties - Haaretz - Israel News
The first question Obama should ask is, Do you think we are absolute fools about what has been going on with settlements?
And should make it clear, that if Israel will not really work for a two state solution, the US must work for a polity - perhaps via cantonment - that admits the current one state reality in which circa 45% of the population are treated as B-class subjects.
Israel has enjoyed a 'waiting period' in its relationship with Obama, but this period will end when Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visits Washington on May 18. Obama and other senior administration officials have made it clear to Netanyahu that he should not waste their time by turning the visit into a public relations campaign; rather, he must propose practical steps for furthering the diplomatic process and improving the lot of the Palestinians. Netanyahu wants to place Iran at the top of the agenda, but U.S. officials will explain that Israel will have to give something in return.
The first question Obama should ask is, Do you think we are absolute fools about what has been going on with settlements?
And should make it clear, that if Israel will not really work for a two state solution, the US must work for a polity - perhaps via cantonment - that admits the current one state reality in which circa 45% of the population are treated as B-class subjects.
Stephen Fry's letter to his 16-year-old self | Media | The Guardian
Stephen Fry's letter to his 16-year-old self | Media | The Guardian
I found this interesting and moving.
I wrote a letter to my future self back when I was 20. Sadly I lost it.
But Stephen is right - love and lack of it are the most important things.
Just who was the young, arrogant and confused man to whom Stephen Fry recently felt compelled to write a long and heartfelt letter? Himself, 35 years ago"
I found this interesting and moving.
I wrote a letter to my future self back when I was 20. Sadly I lost it.
But Stephen is right - love and lack of it are the most important things.
There is NO Alternatiive

Tesco unravels toilet paper's carbon footprint | Environment | guardian.co.uk
Steel yourself, here's the news you've been waiting to hear: the carbon footprint of each lavatorial wipe you make. (It's certainly news that Sheryl Crow will be no doubt desperate to hear, given her previous thoughts on this issue). Drum roll, please: Tesco says that each sheet of its recycled toilet roll uses '1.1g of carbon' compared to 1.8g for its standard toilet roll.
Let's give that some sort of context. Google declared earlier this year that each Google search generates 0.2g of CO2. So now we know that using one sheet of recycled toilet paper has the same carbon footprint as performing five-and-a-half Google searches.
We now also know that you would have to get through 200 sheets of toilet paper before you matched the carbon footprint of one carton of orange juice. Or 773 sheets of toiler paper before you equalled the carbon footprint of just one washload's worth of biological washing powder. We know all this because the Carbon Trust, who do the sums for Tesco, tells us so.
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Our Next PM on Ecstasy?

At least according to Guido.
It probably what makes him such an empathic guy.
There is more at Londoner's Diary
With this video. Way to go Dave. (if it was Dave) [And if it was not Dave, well we all still need to feel that groove] {Daddio}
This blessed plot
This royal throne of kings, this sceptred isle,
This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars,
This other Eden, demi-paradise,
This fortress built by Nature for herself
Against infection and the hand of war,
This happy breed of men, this little world,
This precious stone set in the silver sea,
Which serves it in the office of a wall
Or as a moat defensive to a house,
Against the envy of less happier lands,—
This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England.
One of my former students, an American, wrote to me recently about freedom and speech in the UK.
I’d love to hear your take on some things going on in the UK concerning freedom of speech. I’m thinking of incidents like the Scientology protest arrest and the problems Fred Phelps and Geert Wilders had getting into the country (I wouldn’t really want them here either). Specifically, I’m interested in what you see as the primary motivation for restrictions on religiously offensive speech. I see several possibilities: 1) concern over civil unrest and violence that could follow anything the Islamic community might interpret as blasphemy, 2) the logical extension of laws intended to prevent jihadist speech in mosques to Christian (Phelps) and right-wing (Wilders) nut jobs as well, or 3) the simple desire of liberal political correctness to make sure no group is ever offended. If you have some time I’d love to hear your thoughts on this in a post of some kind. Do people there even see this as an issue? It seems odd to hear about this type of stuff in places so much like the United States because it seems like these things could never happen here. Knock on wood.
My response
Actually as a practical matter entry for extremists speakers, at least from Europe, is probably easier here than in the US. These were very much rare cases. What is different here is that hate speech laws, and the Race Relations Act going back to 1968, also make some domestic speech that would be protected in the US liable to prosecution here in the UK. Such prosecutions are very rare.
Some people here do worry about Islamic unrest, but the primary motivation is the desire of people in the UK for a safe and quiet life.
We live here on an Island than can easily be self-sufficient in food, that (unless the gulf stream stops) will do relatively well out of global warming, and where we have no earthquakes or hurricanes. Natural disasters are rare.
Although there are continual complaints about crime, it is incredibly low in the UK. In my city of Manchester, the rounding up of one gang has reduced all gun crimes from around 36 per year to 3 per year in 2008. I.e. in a Police area encompassing 2.5 million people, we had three gun crime murders. Compare that to Jacksonville in Florida where a city of 800,000 saw perhaps 120 gun crime murders.
For the most part British people hold strong opinions but reject any violent political ideology.
For the sake of safety, even though politicians are despised, people in general are willing to allow the state to do a great deal that might be suspect in order to preserve public order. In return the state is very mild. For example, in a country of 60 million people only 80,000 are in jail.
It's a different society here than in the US. It's not really less free, although there is more state surveillance. The major point, however, is that public policy is above all ordered to public safety and the vast majority of people or all political persuasions support that.
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
RIP Bea Arthur

Beatrice Arthur - Telegraph
She was My Golden Girl. I always wanted to be Blanche, but I just know I am a Dorothy.
Swine Flu: The Value of Life
According to the BBC
The UK has 33 million flu/Tamiflu treatments stockpiled, for a pop of 60 million.
India has 2 million treatments for a pop of c 1 Billion (.0025%)
It's true the UK is a richer country, but India spends more of GOLD imports than any other country, and is now doing Moon shots.
The inescapable conclusion, however politically incorrect, is that a some fundamental level the UK government values individual life more than the Indian Government.
The UK has 33 million flu/Tamiflu treatments stockpiled, for a pop of 60 million.
India has 2 million treatments for a pop of c 1 Billion (.0025%)
It's true the UK is a richer country, but India spends more of GOLD imports than any other country, and is now doing Moon shots.
The inescapable conclusion, however politically incorrect, is that a some fundamental level the UK government values individual life more than the Indian Government.
The Lives of Others: Britain 2009?
The Lives of Others (Das Leben der Anderen) is an award winning 2006 film about the Stasi in East Germany, yet the lessons from the film has striking parallels with Great Britain in 2009. Here subtitles are added to the trailer of the film. Numerous references in the subtitles are from news stories in spring 2009 in the UK.
Via Iain Dale
What Would Brits Think about Torture?
Gawker - Spook's Torture Lie Made Waterboarding Cool - John kiriakou
I guess we just assume MI5 does it as necessary.
"A 'former' CIA officer named John Kiriakou told ABC News that spies broke an al Qaeda terrorist in '30, 35 seconds,' using waterboarding. The story spread everywhere. Of course it was a horrific lie.
Kiriakou told ABC's Brian Ross the alleged terrorist, Abu Zubayadah, broke in less than a minute and 'from that day on he answered every question.' The story spread to the major press outlets, and conservatives like Rush Limbaugh and National Review's Jonah Goldberg used it to defend waterboarding.
I guess we just assume MI5 does it as necessary.
Lazy Ants
Scientist at Work - Anna Dornhaus - Researcher Studies Ants and Bees, One by One - NYTimes.com
Dr. Dornhaus found that fast ants took one to five minutes to perform a task — collecting a piece of food, fetching a sand-grain stone to build a wall, transporting a brood item — while slow ants took more than an hour, and sometimes two. And she discovered that about 50 percent of the other ants do not do any work at all. In fact, small colonies may sometimes rely on a single hyperactive overachiever.
Why do some worker ants lean on their shovels and let the rest of the workers do all the work? “It’s like students living together — you’ll always find one will have a lower threshold for doing the washing up and will end up always doing it all,” she said.
Perhaps the division of labor — which the economist Adam Smith linked to human achievement — may not be the key to ant success. Possibly, Dr. Dornhaus said, “the lazing ants are resting, or are waiting in reserve in case something goes wrong.” Or the laggards may be cooking up some biochemical nest protection. (All ant species manufacture a fungicide to stave off mold in their nests.) Or, she said, “It’s possible they aren’t doing anything at all.”
Monday, April 27, 2009
Appleyard: Torture
Thought Experiments : The Blog: Torture
Yep.
Whatever else is decided, it should be quite clear that if Lynndie England went to prison, then so should a lot of much more senior people, probably including, at least, Rumsfeld.
Yep.
Andrew Sullivan on the Need for Justice
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan
I agree with Andrew. We just need to wait eight years.
"We don't want vengeance. We want America back. And we are going to fight on and on until we get it back."
I agree with Andrew. We just need to wait eight years.
Prosecuting Bush, Cheney, and Rice
There is now clear evidence that the regime of President GW Bush, R Cheney, aided by C Rice authorized and promulgated a regime of torture.
I am far more left wing than almost any American, but I just want to say that I think David Frum (a decent Republican) has a point in objecting to any prosecutions right now.
Cheney is acting unbelievably badly (compare him to how restrained George HW Bush was about Clinton) and needs to be called on that. And I agree Bush should be tried. But by the next president.
Look, Gore was cheated in 2000, and he could have made things very messy. But ultimately he decided that the, while clearly no constitution is perfect, his own ambitions were not enough to force a destablising contest with the Supreme Court.
Lincoln (Habeas Corpus) and Roosevelt (Japanese internment) clearly committed constitutional violations, but, fortunately from one point of view, died before these could become an issue.
I am no fan of American exceptionalism, but in many ways the US remains the last best hope for good in Human Government. A pattern of wrecking vengeance on previous governments would utterly destroy one of its strengths.
Obama should announce that violators of the Geneva Conventions may face prosecution under his presidency, but that, because of the need to preserve the stable constitution, any prosecution of Bush, Cheney, or Rice must wait until AFTER his presidency.
I am far more left wing than almost any American, but I just want to say that I think David Frum (a decent Republican) has a point in objecting to any prosecutions right now.
Cheney is acting unbelievably badly (compare him to how restrained George HW Bush was about Clinton) and needs to be called on that. And I agree Bush should be tried. But by the next president.
Look, Gore was cheated in 2000, and he could have made things very messy. But ultimately he decided that the, while clearly no constitution is perfect, his own ambitions were not enough to force a destablising contest with the Supreme Court.
Lincoln (Habeas Corpus) and Roosevelt (Japanese internment) clearly committed constitutional violations, but, fortunately from one point of view, died before these could become an issue.
I am no fan of American exceptionalism, but in many ways the US remains the last best hope for good in Human Government. A pattern of wrecking vengeance on previous governments would utterly destroy one of its strengths.
Obama should announce that violators of the Geneva Conventions may face prosecution under his presidency, but that, because of the need to preserve the stable constitution, any prosecution of Bush, Cheney, or Rice must wait until AFTER his presidency.
Epidemics and Fibonacci
I have not worked this out, but I would like to know if the the plotting of this epidemic is looking (roughly) like a Fibonacci sequence - i.e. 1,1,2,3,5,8,13,21
If so, that is bad. Mother Nature loves Fibonacci sequences
UDDATE: For a Saner View see What Did You Expect from scienceblogs.com
If so, that is bad. Mother Nature loves Fibonacci sequences
UDDATE: For a Saner View see What Did You Expect from scienceblogs.com
Nature Hates Republicans
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan
When House Appropriations Committee chairman David Obey, the Wisconsin Democrat who has long championed investment in pandemic preparation, included roughly $900 million for that purpose in this year's emergency stimulus bill, he was ridiculed by conservative operatives and congressional Republicans.
Earthquake in Mexico City
Classical Music Blogging
I don't really cover classical music here, although it is a major interest of mine.
For a the most lively Classical Music blog see Michael White in the Telegraph.
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/michael_white
For a the most lively Classical Music blog see Michael White in the Telegraph.
http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/michael_white
James Purnell: The Minister for Attacking Chavs

Minister James Purnell accused of leaving his flat 'like a pigsty' - Telegraph
James Purnell, the Work and Pensions Secretary, lost his deposit after his landlord claimed he had spilt wine on the wall, stained the carpets and left the kitchen in a filthy condition.
The minister, tipped as a future Labour leader, claimed �100 a month for cleaning and a further �586 for repairs on the duplex flat, which has a roof terrace overlooking Covent Garden in central London.
End the University as We Know It - Or More Crap from the NYT
Op-Contributor - End the University as We Know It - Op-Ed - NYTimes.com
I have not (yet) published my dissertation on Women's Bodies, Men's Souls: Sanctity and Gender in Byzantium, although I still have hopes.
But this NYT op-ed piece is both americano-centric, and ignores the reality of what a dissertation is about. A dissertation is meant to be narrow. Anything that is not narrow is little more than an opinion piece.
Furthermore, it is worthwhile in and of itself to try for a limited number of years to engage one's mind in an intense understanding of at least one thing.
There is an observable and significant difference in the teaching style and abilities of Ph.D. vs Masters degree holders. Typically masters students have no real grasp of the hierarchy of sources (there are exceptions, of course). This may be fine in introductory level courses, but not more focused courses.
And ultimately there is the elitist claim. Studying at the highest level (although the US/UK PH.D. falls short of some of the German or Finnish highest degree strands), makes one in some sense a better person.
Sadly my Greek is good enough to to translate from what is essentially a trot. But I get more from Homer in Fagles or Lattimore's translation.
But I firmly believe, and assert, that the by now very rare ability to read and enjoy Homer in one's head - where one grasps the references and subtleties of grammar makes one, in some sense a better person. Someone indeed who has made good use of the time they are given in this universe where consciousness is gift we hardly yet grasp.
I can fully grasp Shakespeare, and at least some of Voltaire. And I think that makes me in some sense a better person that someone who only grasps techno music.
I am prepared to give equal kudos to those mathematicians who can see the Platonic beauty of maths.
I refuse to the cowed by the grade-grubbing Wikipedia copying students who claim to be "professionals" without the ability to appreciate the grand tradition.
There is no longer a market for books modeled on the medieval dissertation, with more footnotes than text. As financial pressures on university presses continue to mount, publication of dissertations, and with it scholarly certification, is almost impossible. (The average university press print run of a dissertation that has been converted into a book is less than 500, and sales are usually considerably lower.)
I have not (yet) published my dissertation on Women's Bodies, Men's Souls: Sanctity and Gender in Byzantium, although I still have hopes.
But this NYT op-ed piece is both americano-centric, and ignores the reality of what a dissertation is about. A dissertation is meant to be narrow. Anything that is not narrow is little more than an opinion piece.
Furthermore, it is worthwhile in and of itself to try for a limited number of years to engage one's mind in an intense understanding of at least one thing.
There is an observable and significant difference in the teaching style and abilities of Ph.D. vs Masters degree holders. Typically masters students have no real grasp of the hierarchy of sources (there are exceptions, of course). This may be fine in introductory level courses, but not more focused courses.
And ultimately there is the elitist claim. Studying at the highest level (although the US/UK PH.D. falls short of some of the German or Finnish highest degree strands), makes one in some sense a better person.
Sadly my Greek is good enough to to translate from what is essentially a trot. But I get more from Homer in Fagles or Lattimore's translation.
But I firmly believe, and assert, that the by now very rare ability to read and enjoy Homer in one's head - where one grasps the references and subtleties of grammar makes one, in some sense a better person. Someone indeed who has made good use of the time they are given in this universe where consciousness is gift we hardly yet grasp.
I can fully grasp Shakespeare, and at least some of Voltaire. And I think that makes me in some sense a better person that someone who only grasps techno music.
I am prepared to give equal kudos to those mathematicians who can see the Platonic beauty of maths.
I refuse to the cowed by the grade-grubbing Wikipedia copying students who claim to be "professionals" without the ability to appreciate the grand tradition.
Twenty Firsts Meme
Via Iain Dale
First Job
Hiring out deckchairs on Saltcoats beach in 1976
First Real Job
Coordinator of volunteers, YWCA, Edinburgh.
First post Ph.D. Job; Asst. Prof. Brooklyn College.
First Role in Politics
Joined Labour Party in Edinburgh Central, 1983.
Active in London Pride, Act-UP/NYC, and Queer Nation/NY
First Car
A horrid Honda Prelude that blew three cylinders within 3 months. Extra fact: first ever control of a car by myself, was after buying said car at Madison Avenue and 36th St.
First Record
Andre Previn's recording of Rachmaninov's Second Symphony.
First Football Match
Manchester Utd v Huddersfield, circa 1972. At Old Trafford (walkable from where I lived). I saw George Best, Bobby Charlton, and Denis Law play
First Concert
Either Leonard Cohen in Edinburgh or Joan Baez in Caesarea Israel.
First Country Visited
USSR (Now Ukraine) [We saw Kiev, Leningrad and Moscow]. On a High School trip from Ardrossan Academy in 1977. The USSR under Brezhenev did not look especially bad, and from then on I opposed any notion of dropping nuclear weapons on these people.I enjoyed the day trip to a Komosol camp and singing Kalinka. I was also cruised in an art gallery in Kiev, although, alas, I did not realise what was happening at the time.
First TV Appearance
On a conflict-style debate show, representing Queer Nation, in Detroit, 1988
First Political Speech
Attacking abortion in a debate at High School
First Boyfriend
Leo A. Who I met in 1992, and lived with for 4 years; and with whom I am still best friends.
First Encounter with a Famous Person
Meeting Chris Smith MP, on a Pride London march.
First Brush With Death
Testing HIV Positive in 1990
First House/Flat Owned
Never owned a house or flat.
First Film Seen at a Cinema
Sound of Music at Gaumont Manchester. Saw Batman and Robin the week after. Then Dumbo. My Mum was training me to be queer.
First Time on the Radio
Defending Pope John Paul II as a an economic radical on WBAI in New York
First Politician I Met
Michael Ancram MP, Robin Cook MP, or Chris Smith MP. I recall one of them was gay.
First Book I Remember Reading
Something about helicopters by Enid Blyton
First Visit to the London Palladium
Sneaked in to see La Cage au Folles, 1986
First Election
1979. I voted Conservative vs. Robin Cook in Edinburgh central on the abortion issue. Thinking that through moved me left. Far Far Left. I liked the Bennite book MANIFESTO in 1982. I still do. Except I would keep the Queen.
First Political Speech
When I told my Mum, Harold Wilson's "White Hot Technology Speech" was hot shit.
First Job
Hiring out deckchairs on Saltcoats beach in 1976
First Real Job
Coordinator of volunteers, YWCA, Edinburgh.
First post Ph.D. Job; Asst. Prof. Brooklyn College.
First Role in Politics
Joined Labour Party in Edinburgh Central, 1983.
Active in London Pride, Act-UP/NYC, and Queer Nation/NY
First Car
A horrid Honda Prelude that blew three cylinders within 3 months. Extra fact: first ever control of a car by myself, was after buying said car at Madison Avenue and 36th St.
First Record
Andre Previn's recording of Rachmaninov's Second Symphony.
First Football Match
Manchester Utd v Huddersfield, circa 1972. At Old Trafford (walkable from where I lived). I saw George Best, Bobby Charlton, and Denis Law play
First Concert
Either Leonard Cohen in Edinburgh or Joan Baez in Caesarea Israel.
First Country Visited
USSR (Now Ukraine) [We saw Kiev, Leningrad and Moscow]. On a High School trip from Ardrossan Academy in 1977. The USSR under Brezhenev did not look especially bad, and from then on I opposed any notion of dropping nuclear weapons on these people.I enjoyed the day trip to a Komosol camp and singing Kalinka. I was also cruised in an art gallery in Kiev, although, alas, I did not realise what was happening at the time.
First TV Appearance
On a conflict-style debate show, representing Queer Nation, in Detroit, 1988
First Political Speech
Attacking abortion in a debate at High School
First Boyfriend
Leo A. Who I met in 1992, and lived with for 4 years; and with whom I am still best friends.
First Encounter with a Famous Person
Meeting Chris Smith MP, on a Pride London march.
First Brush With Death
Testing HIV Positive in 1990
First House/Flat Owned
Never owned a house or flat.
First Film Seen at a Cinema
Sound of Music at Gaumont Manchester. Saw Batman and Robin the week after. Then Dumbo. My Mum was training me to be queer.
First Time on the Radio
Defending Pope John Paul II as a an economic radical on WBAI in New York
First Politician I Met
Michael Ancram MP, Robin Cook MP, or Chris Smith MP. I recall one of them was gay.
First Book I Remember Reading
Something about helicopters by Enid Blyton
First Visit to the London Palladium
Sneaked in to see La Cage au Folles, 1986
First Election
1979. I voted Conservative vs. Robin Cook in Edinburgh central on the abortion issue. Thinking that through moved me left. Far Far Left. I liked the Bennite book MANIFESTO in 1982. I still do. Except I would keep the Queen.
First Political Speech
When I told my Mum, Harold Wilson's "White Hot Technology Speech" was hot shit.
Back on Blog: Back from Paris

I just returned from an exhausting charabanc trip (two days travel, one day there) to Paris. It was in reality, a sib-bonding exercise for me and my sister.
She liked Paris and especially Notre-Dame. But did not feel up to visiting any museum.
I should say that my sister, who is no historian nor intellectual, did lead me to look at the polychrome scenes from the passion and life of Christ in the ambulatory around the altar in a way I have never looked at them before.
Also, I suppose I leached on her wonder as we sat in the nave and "observed" mass. She had never really bothered to sit down in the nave of a medieval Cathedral before. I felt again, through here, the sheer stunning perfection of Notre Dame.
Other people on the charabanc declared that Paris was "boring" and "too cold".
Oy. Vey.
Thursday, April 23, 2009
Shakespeare too (Today is the Anniversay of his Death)
SONNET 104 (written to a male lover)
To me, fair friend, you never can be old,
For as you were when first your eye I eyed,
Such seems your beauty still. Three winters cold
Have from the forests shook three summers' pride,
Three beauteous springs to yellow autumn turn'd
In process of the seasons have I seen,
Three April perfumes in three hot Junes burn'd,
Since first I saw you fresh, which yet are green.
Ah, yet doth beauty, like a dial-hand,
Steal from his figure and no pace perceived;
So your sweet hue, which methinks still doth stand,
Hath motion and mine eye may be deceived:
For fear of which, hear this, thou age unbred;
Ere you were born was beauty's summer dead.
See Mabillard, Amanda. An Analysis of Shakespeare's Sonnet 104. Shakespeare Online. 2000. (23/4/2009) < http://www.shakespeare-online.com/sonnets/104detail.html >.
To me, fair friend, you never can be old,
For as you were when first your eye I eyed,
Such seems your beauty still. Three winters cold
Have from the forests shook three summers' pride,
Three beauteous springs to yellow autumn turn'd
In process of the seasons have I seen,
Three April perfumes in three hot Junes burn'd,
Since first I saw you fresh, which yet are green.
Ah, yet doth beauty, like a dial-hand,
Steal from his figure and no pace perceived;
So your sweet hue, which methinks still doth stand,
Hath motion and mine eye may be deceived:
For fear of which, hear this, thou age unbred;
Ere you were born was beauty's summer dead.
See Mabillard, Amanda. An Analysis of Shakespeare's Sonnet 104. Shakespeare Online. 2000. (23/4/2009) < http://www.shakespeare-online.com/sonnets/104detail.html >.
St. George: A Gay Saint? (Today is his Feast Day)

St. George is, along with St. Nicholas, without any question among the most popular of all saints in history. The odd thing is that nothing whatsoever can be established about him as a historical figure. Indeed the among earliest references to this cult in the West involve papal condemnations of the myths surrounding him.
So how can George be included in a list of "queer" saints. For two reasons - iconographic and textual.
Textual
No one reading early texts about George can fail to be impressed by the explicit homoeroticism in them. George at one stage is about to marry, but is prevented by Christ. As the text said "[George] did not know that Christ was keeping him as a pure virginal bridegroom for himself". (Budge, 282) Later on after mind-boggling escapades [George is killed and resurrected a number or times in his myths], Christ welcomes George into Heaven with bridal imagery: - "And the Lord said to the blessed George, Hail, My George! Hail beloved of myself and of My Angels…I swear by My right hand, Oh my beloved one that I will establish a covenant with thee that when thou shalt bow thyself upon thy spiritual face in heaven and shall come with all they congregation to worship the holy Trinity, all the saints know thee by reason of the honour which I will show thee, O My beloved… " (Budge 320-21).
In these texts, here from Coptic versions, George is presented as the bridegroom of Christ. Bridal imagery is quite common in discourse about Christ, but usually male saints are made into "brides of Christ" [see Carolyn Walker Bynum's work on this], but with George a same sex marital imagery is used.
Iconographic:
George is among the most common subjects of religious art. His iconographic type is fixed - he is a young beardless warrior. It is worth noting that some commentators have seen appeal of this figure as androgynous. Here are the comments of Christopher Walter, a recent commentator on the cult of George:-
'There can be not doubt that [George] had an exceptional affective appeal, difficult perhaps for us to grasp, since the Byzantines have not bequeathed us many empirical descriptions of their feelings. Some reconstruction can be tentatively undertaken….Thomas Matthews has studied the affective attitude of the Byzantines towards their icons and the saints represented on the icons. `One was supposed to fall in love with these saints.' Or elsewhere: 'The involvement of the Orthodox beholder with his painted images was complete…The believer entered a world of images in a way the modern view of paintings cannot accomplish". However, empathy as a characteristic of human psychology, must keep pace with development and changes in artistic media. It may not be amiss therefore to quote James Baldwin's description of a budding actor in a film. It seems to me to give some insight into the way that a Byzantine saw an icon of St. George:`…The face of a man, of a tormented man. Yet, in precisely the way that great music depends, ultimately, on a great silence, this masculinity was defined and made powerful by something which was not masculine. It was not feminine either and something….resisted the word androgynous. It was a quality to which numbers of persons would respond without knowing what it was that they were responding. There was a great force in face and a great gentleness…It was a face which suggested, resonantly in the depths the truth about our natures'" (Walter, 320)
In addition to all the above, George is patron saint of scouting, chosen as such by Baden Powell. There is a webpage for George, Patron of Scouts!
Select bibliography
Budge, Earnest Wallis, The Martyrdom and Miracles of St. George of Cappodocia: The Coptic Texts, (London: D. Nutt, 1888)
Bynum, Caroline Walker, Jesus as Mother: Studies in the Spirituality of the High Middle Ages, (Berkeley: 1982)
Walter, Christopher, "The Origins of the Cult of St. George", Revue des études byzantines 53 (1995), 295-326
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
Thatcher, Heath, and Cameron
Mrs Thatcher: an apology | And another thing...
Any man who finds himself on a bus after the age of 30 can count himself a failure.
Tom Harris devotes a blog to saying Thatcher did not say this. Fair enough if she did not say it. I, in fact have never heard it attributed to her.
But Thatcher did little to help public transport, hated railways, and privatized BA.
Look, we are about to face a period of Tory government. The goal is that it does limited harm and that Labour can reconstitute itself to be electable in 4 years time.
Cameron is Heath, not Thatcher.
Any man who finds himself on a bus after the age of 30 can count himself a failure.
Tom Harris devotes a blog to saying Thatcher did not say this. Fair enough if she did not say it. I, in fact have never heard it attributed to her.
But Thatcher did little to help public transport, hated railways, and privatized BA.
Look, we are about to face a period of Tory government. The goal is that it does limited harm and that Labour can reconstitute itself to be electable in 4 years time.
Cameron is Heath, not Thatcher.
More American Nazis
The Case for the ‘Torture Memos’ by Rich Lowry on National Review Online
"Rightly considered, the memos should be a source of pride"
"Rightly considered, the memos should be a source of pride"
List of Likely CIA Prisoners Who Are Still Missing - ProPublica
List of Likely CIA Prisoners Who Are Still Missing - ProPublica
Does anyone recall when one of the reasons for going to war against Saddam was that he used torture and and maintained secret prisons.
The CIA has not released the names of terrorism suspects it held in secret detention with the exception of 14 who were transferred to Guantanamo Bay, in September 2006. Human rights groups have tried to track those identities using publicly available information about high-profile captures, eyewitness accounts from former detainees and family inquiries. In June 2007, six human rights groups released the names of nearly three dozen apparent CIA prisoners [1] (PDF) whose fates remained unknown. We've updated that list based on the most current information available to Human Rights Watch. (For more details, also see our accompanying story [2].)
Does anyone recall when one of the reasons for going to war against Saddam was that he used torture and and maintained secret prisons.
The New Eichmann
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan
... is when you can link the torture to the obsession with finding a link between al Qaeda and Saddam. McClatchy's story is the most eye-popping of the last week in my view, certainly a twist I didn't fully foresee:
A former senior U.S. intelligence official familiar with the interrogation issue said that Cheney and former Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld demanded that the interrogators find evidence of al Qaida-Iraq collaboration.
"There were two reasons why these interrogations were so persistent, and why extreme methods were used," the former senior intelligence official said on condition of anonymity because of the issue's sensitivity.
"The main one is that everyone was worried about some kind of follow-up attack (after 9/11). But for most of 2002 and into 2003, Cheney and Rumsfeld, especially, were also demanding proof of the links between al Qaida and Iraq that (former Iraqi exile leader Ahmed) Chalabi and others had told them were there."
It was during this period that CIA interrogators waterboarded two alleged top al Qaida detainees repeatedly — Abu Zubaydah at least 83 times in August 2002 and Khalid Sheik Muhammed 183 times in March 2003 — according to a newly released Justice Department document.
"There was constant pressure on the intelligence agencies and the interrogators to do whatever it took to get that information out of the detainees, especially the few high-value ones we had, and when people kept coming up empty, they were told by Cheney's and Rumsfeld's people to push harder," he continued.
"Cheney's and Rumsfeld's people were told repeatedly, by CIA . . . and by others, that there wasn't any reliable intelligence that pointed to operational ties between bin Laden and Saddam, and that no such ties were likely because the two were fundamentally enemies, not allies."
Senior administration officials, however, "blew that off and kept insisting that we'd overlooked something, that the interrogators weren't pushing hard enough, that there had to be something more we could do to get that information," he said.
The first reason to use torture is to prevent a ticking time bomb that could kill millions; the second reason is as a routine part of intelligence gathering; the third is to produce false confessions to justify a war already planned. Torture is a powerful weapon, isn't it? Look how many it corrupted so completely and so fast.
Via Andrew Sulliavn
Criminalizing Conservatism
Power Line - Criminalizing Conservatism
Good on Obama. When conservatism amounts to nothing more than the defence of torture, it deserves to be destroyed.
Many liberals don't just want to defeat conservatives at the polls, they want to send them to jail. Toward that end, they have sometimes tried to criminalize what are essentially policy differences. President Obama hinted at another step in that direction when he said today that he is open to the idea of bringing criminal charges against the Justice Department lawyers who wrote opinions to the effect that waterboarding and other harsh interrogation methods could legally be used on al Qaeda detainees. Obama said the question was a complicated one, and the decision will ultimately be made by Attorney General Eric Holder.
Good on Obama. When conservatism amounts to nothing more than the defence of torture, it deserves to be destroyed.
The UK Budget
It was at least a Labour budget - not vindictive against the poor.
Sadly, I still think the Tories will win the next election, and I expect to see the sheer vindictiveness of that party on display. In terms of tax rates, the Lib Dem proposal to lift income taxes altogether from low paid workers was the best and should have been adopted.
Sadly, I still think the Tories will win the next election, and I expect to see the sheer vindictiveness of that party on display. In terms of tax rates, the Lib Dem proposal to lift income taxes altogether from low paid workers was the best and should have been adopted.
Tuesday, April 21, 2009
Nine men arrested over suspected terror plot released to UK borders agency
Nine men arrested over suspected terror plot released to UK borders agency | UK news | guardian.co.uk
Why are these men being deported if they face no charges.
Update (Guardian): More on Terror Suspects. A disgrace. http://tinyurl.com/ce9fuj
Why are these men being deported if they face no charges.
Update (Guardian): More on Terror Suspects. A disgrace. http://tinyurl.com/ce9fuj
Pox Britannica?
Howard Jacobsen: Pox Britannica
People here are sharply more critical of Israel here than in the US. I have to say that after the Gaza war, I simply want a two state solution imposed. That is not perfect. It would be better, in my book, to have one state, but no one there wants that. People here will be vocally anti-Israel, but that does not creep over among native English people. Virtually all anti-Semitic incidents seem to come from over excited, and somewhat marginalized, Muslim youths.
So, yes, at a dinner party, a pro-Israel Jewish person might find a lot of dissent. But among the dinner party going classes, no actual antisemitism.
There is something in the air here, something you can smell, but also, in a number of cases, something more immediately affronting to Jews. It is important not to exaggerate. Most English Jews walk safely through their streets, express themselves freely, enjoy the friendship of non-Jews, and feel no less confidently a part of English life than they ever have. Organizations monitoring anti-Jewish incidents in England have reported a dramatic increase after Gaza: the daubing of slogans such as 'kill the jews' on walls and bus shelters in Jewish neighborhoods, abuse of Jewish children on school playgrounds, arson attacks on synagogues, physical assaults on Jews conspicuous by their yarmulkes or shtreimels. But, while these incidents ought not to be treated blithely, they are still exceptional occurrences.
And yet, in the tone of the debate, in the spirit of the national conversation about Israel, in the slow seepage of familiar anti-Semitic calumnies into the conversation--there, it seems to me, one can find growing reason for English Jews to be concerned.
People here are sharply more critical of Israel here than in the US. I have to say that after the Gaza war, I simply want a two state solution imposed. That is not perfect. It would be better, in my book, to have one state, but no one there wants that. People here will be vocally anti-Israel, but that does not creep over among native English people. Virtually all anti-Semitic incidents seem to come from over excited, and somewhat marginalized, Muslim youths.
So, yes, at a dinner party, a pro-Israel Jewish person might find a lot of dissent. But among the dinner party going classes, no actual antisemitism.
The Deflation Lie
Deflation returns to Britain for first time since 1960 | Business | guardian.co.uk
This may be true if you drive a car and pay a mortgage but the deflation figures published in the UK today are sheer bunkum for the poor.
Here's why.
*Food. General food inflation is still rising, but hidden in those figures, and explaining why supermarkets are making mega profits is that the "low-end" non-branded items on which low income people were already relaying have shot up in price by 20-30%.
This is from my experience of ASDA
Tomatoes: up from 55p to 88p over the year
ASDA Butter: up from 67p to 87p over the year.
Mincemeat: up by about 20%
A Can of Tuna: 33p to 48p
Rice: 55p to 88p
[Canned tuna, brown rice, and onions is a cheap nutritious meal - but it has doubled in price.]
*Gas and Electricity
Southern Electric raised prices by around 40% last year, and reaped profit over the winter, even as oil market prices plummeted.
*Bus Fares. First Group in Manchester has increased the Fare from where I live to the Town center from 1.20 to 1.50.
For people living on low incomes virtually our expenses are on food, fuel, and bus travel. There is no way these costs have gone down over the past year, In fact there has been more like an 8-12% increase.
There is no evidence that the Labour government is offering anywhere near enough help.
Deflation returned to Britain for the first time in nearly five decades last month as prices measured by the retail price index (RPI) were lower than the same time a year ago.
The Office for National Statistics said the RPI was 0.4% lower in March than it had been in March 2008. That was the first negative reading since March 1960, when Harold Macmillan was prime minister and John F Kennedy was running for the US presidency.
This may be true if you drive a car and pay a mortgage but the deflation figures published in the UK today are sheer bunkum for the poor.
Here's why.
*Food. General food inflation is still rising, but hidden in those figures, and explaining why supermarkets are making mega profits is that the "low-end" non-branded items on which low income people were already relaying have shot up in price by 20-30%.
This is from my experience of ASDA
Tomatoes: up from 55p to 88p over the year
ASDA Butter: up from 67p to 87p over the year.
Mincemeat: up by about 20%
A Can of Tuna: 33p to 48p
Rice: 55p to 88p
[Canned tuna, brown rice, and onions is a cheap nutritious meal - but it has doubled in price.]
*Gas and Electricity
Southern Electric raised prices by around 40% last year, and reaped profit over the winter, even as oil market prices plummeted.
*Bus Fares. First Group in Manchester has increased the Fare from where I live to the Town center from 1.20 to 1.50.
For people living on low incomes virtually our expenses are on food, fuel, and bus travel. There is no way these costs have gone down over the past year, In fact there has been more like an 8-12% increase.
There is no evidence that the Labour government is offering anywhere near enough help.
Monday, April 20, 2009
How America became a torture nation
The Daily Dish | By Andrew Sullivan
Via Andrew Sullivan
"When War Crimes Are Punch Lines
Chris Buckley becomes Rush Limbaugh. If you want to know how America became a torture nation, read it."
Via Andrew Sullivan
Sunday, April 19, 2009
Gathering Storm
And a take down by the Colbert Report.
In the U.K. it should be a key demand for LGBT groups that Civil Partnerhips be allowed to be civil marriages, and that those churches/etc (Unitarian. Quaker, MCC, Independent Catholic Church, Liberal Judaism) that want to celebrate religious ceremonies be able to do so.
When Computers Know More About You than You Know About Yourself.
I just logged on to Youtube and was present as recommended videos:
This is disturbing.
I mean, why are there no Susan Boyle videos?
Jesus of Nazareth (22 of 41)
No Answers, with In Paradisum, by Point Valid with Catherine Asaro
Project Mayhem : Last Part Of Fight Club.
Tom Robinson "Still loving you"
Perhaps Love - John Denver & Placido Domingo
Danny Boyle winning the Oscar® for "Slumdog Millionaire"
Judy Garland - The Trolley Song (Meet Me in St. Louis)
My Corner of the Sky
This is disturbing.
I mean, why are there no Susan Boyle videos?
A degree in spin

A degree in spin: PM's sacked adviser's Cambridge theory of how to use rumours and riots
The Mail on Sunday article argues that Gordon Brown's disastrous adviser, Damian McBride, revealed something about himself in his M.Phil. thesis, which argued that
* The American race riots in the Sixties showed that violence is needed to bring political change.
* The rumour mill is a good way to spark riots.
* And in academic language he even appeared to suggest that riots increase the amount of sexual activity and drug-taking.
Hmmm. I don't think it's really that easy to draw links between what you write academically and live in real life.
I wrote my Ph.d. dissertation (i.e. "thesis" in Brit speak)about sanctity and gender among Byzantine saints. I, for instance, have never really attempted to be a Byzantine Virgin.
Oh, and Christos Anesti to Orthodox readers.
Ian Hislop Lays Into Bloggers?
Iain Dale's Diary: Ian Hislop Lays Into Bloggers
I'm a little surprised to see extent of the anti Private Eye animus, and the sello-out charges on Ian Hislop among Iain Dale's commentators.
I agree with poster Alex Creek - any single page of Private Eye digs up more on crap governance in this country than a month of Guido. Or any blog so far.
It remains, as far as I concerned, the most essential reading matter published in Britain.
I'm a little surprised to see extent of the anti Private Eye animus, and the sello-out charges on Ian Hislop among Iain Dale's commentators.
I agree with poster Alex Creek - any single page of Private Eye digs up more on crap governance in this country than a month of Guido. Or any blog so far.
It remains, as far as I concerned, the most essential reading matter published in Britain.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

