One of my former students, who is now a Marine Captain, sent me this link to a video of his platton and their lives in Iraq. Actually it's kind of hot in parts, but gives a view of life in Iraq that I have not seen before.
Perspectives from an English Historian who just happens to be Gay, Catholic, and a Democratic Socialist. Now back in the UK after 20 years of living in the United States. The Blog is eclectic in covering all these sides of my Life. Follow on Twitter at PaulBHalsall
Friday, August 11, 2006
Thursday, August 10, 2006
A Feudal Anachronism: Sark
Stuck out in the English Channel, 20 miles off the coast of Normandy and boasting a population of only 600 souls, to its admirers the Isle of Sark represents a redoubt against the modern world.
There is no divorce, cars are banned - the preferred mode of transport is tractor - and even the playing of a radio in a public place is outlawed.
Yet Sark continues to attract wealthy outsiders to its tranquil shores, not just because of this enviably laid-back way of life; there is no income tax and personal property taxes are pegged at paltry levels for the very richest.
The "fief" includes the rugged neighbouring island of Brecqhou, bought by the Barclay brothers, owners of The Telegraph, in 1993 for the sum of £2.33m, where they have erected a fairy-tale castle for the benefit of themselves and family.
Sir David Barclay, who, along with his twin brother, Sir Frederick, argues that behind Sark's bucolic façade resides a political system rotten to the core.
Yesterday in his third "open letter to the Bailiwick of Guernsey" (the legal domain in which the Isle of Sark resides) he took out a full-page advertisement describing the island's ruler, known as the Seigneur, as "the unacceptable face of feudalism".
The Independent, 8/10/2006
Islam and Terror
Islam does not mean terror.
Some of the most sustained areas of general human welfare in history have come under Muslim government. Some of the most sublime art has been created. And some of the greatest literature written.
But, it is equally clear that we have a problem.
The War on Terror is not going to work. A war needs, at the very least, some way of saying that it has been won or lost. As long as we are terrorized, then we have lost.
I have some postulates.
1. You cannot change "hearts and minds" in less than a generation.
2. Equally, after a generation of normality (normalcy to US readers) any conflict can potentially be historicized.
3. We need to create a basis for normal human interchange, even if imperfect, that lasts a generation. There is no quick end. We need to deal with patchwork solutions and inconclusive meetings that stretch on and on until everyone is bored silly.
4. Future technology cannot be predicted, but the future effects of current technology can. Our "Western" technology (cellphones, computers, the Internet, GPS, Television) has an inherent tendency to individuate persons and break ties of clan, religion, and family in favor of desires for self-realization. The more it is diffused, the more "individual" people will become. This has many bad effects, but it has a major benefit in undermining totalitarian systems.
5. When you destroy all the leaders of an organization, the second and third generation successors are less able than the originators.
So what do we do? We let Israel destroy HAMAS and Hezbollah. We weaken by all means possible the leadership in Iran. We search out all active Al-Qaeda cells.
But then we try to create a generation of boring meetings, while letting technological civilization propagate. Israel must stop treating Arabs like garbage. India must allow a majority vote in Kashmir. Somalia must be prevented from becoming an Islamic state. That's a start.
In other words, what is needed is a radical policy of prevarication (or at least procrastination) in order that the population-base of the Islamofascists is corrupted by material desire and individuation.
In countries where you have a social group of teenagers and not radicalized youths, terrorism will not prosper.
Some of the most sustained areas of general human welfare in history have come under Muslim government. Some of the most sublime art has been created. And some of the greatest literature written.
But, it is equally clear that we have a problem.
The War on Terror is not going to work. A war needs, at the very least, some way of saying that it has been won or lost. As long as we are terrorized, then we have lost.
I have some postulates.
1. You cannot change "hearts and minds" in less than a generation.
2. Equally, after a generation of normality (normalcy to US readers) any conflict can potentially be historicized.
3. We need to create a basis for normal human interchange, even if imperfect, that lasts a generation. There is no quick end. We need to deal with patchwork solutions and inconclusive meetings that stretch on and on until everyone is bored silly.
4. Future technology cannot be predicted, but the future effects of current technology can. Our "Western" technology (cellphones, computers, the Internet, GPS, Television) has an inherent tendency to individuate persons and break ties of clan, religion, and family in favor of desires for self-realization. The more it is diffused, the more "individual" people will become. This has many bad effects, but it has a major benefit in undermining totalitarian systems.
5. When you destroy all the leaders of an organization, the second and third generation successors are less able than the originators.
So what do we do? We let Israel destroy HAMAS and Hezbollah. We weaken by all means possible the leadership in Iran. We search out all active Al-Qaeda cells.
But then we try to create a generation of boring meetings, while letting technological civilization propagate. Israel must stop treating Arabs like garbage. India must allow a majority vote in Kashmir. Somalia must be prevented from becoming an Islamic state. That's a start.
In other words, what is needed is a radical policy of prevarication (or at least procrastination) in order that the population-base of the Islamofascists is corrupted by material desire and individuation.
In countries where you have a social group of teenagers and not radicalized youths, terrorism will not prosper.
At least some things seem to turn out all right
I just got back from my two-month CAT Scan for the lymphoma scare I had in June. Thank God, there is no problem. My spleen is a bit enlarged, and I should stop drinking (although I am having a glass with a slice of pizza right now) but there is no lymphadenopathy (I think that is how they spell it).
Boy, was I glad - they see you on the chemo floor and it's not a happy place. The less fortunate people will be in my prayers tonight. Your's too, please.
Boy, was I glad - they see you on the chemo floor and it's not a happy place. The less fortunate people will be in my prayers tonight. Your's too, please.
Lieberman
I am "english eclectic" here, and I do not usually comment on US politics in any detail.
But Joe Lieberman running as an independent, after losing in the Democratic primary in Connecticut, is just Not Cricket. In other words, the guy has succeeded in being both a schlemiel and a putz.
But Joe Lieberman running as an independent, after losing in the Democratic primary in Connecticut, is just Not Cricket. In other words, the guy has succeeded in being both a schlemiel and a putz.
Wednesday, August 09, 2006
Mel and Stuff
I am in no way defending Mel Gibson for his anti-Semitic harangue of a police officer. Mel has detested me and my kind (fags) both verbally and on screen for some good time.
However, I must deny "in vino veritas." I know Freud is not scientific, but as my old friend Fr. Aidan Nichols once remarked, he taught some poetic truths.
As I can attest, when you are drunk, you do an say things that come from the worst part of the Id; they are not who you are, or who you aspire to be.
However, I must deny "in vino veritas." I know Freud is not scientific, but as my old friend Fr. Aidan Nichols once remarked, he taught some poetic truths.
As I can attest, when you are drunk, you do an say things that come from the worst part of the Id; they are not who you are, or who you aspire to be.
It used to be easier to be a....
...Satirist. It's damn tough to do satire these days:
The Onion 8/1/2006
WASHINGTON, DC—In a decisive 1–0 decision Monday, President Bush voted to grant the president the constitutional power to grant himself additional powers.
"As president, I strongly believe that my first duty as president is to support and serve the president," Bush said during a televised address from the East Room of the White House shortly after signing his executive order. "I promise the American people that I will not abuse this new power, unless it becomes necessary to grant myself the power to do so at a later time."
The Onion 8/1/2006
Milk - The NPR Story
Amazon.com now sells food. NPR today reported on Amazon reviewers deciding to deal with Milk. With 499 reviews up as I write this, the reviews are dadaist. There is also a story in the New York Times 8/9/2003.
Update: (as of 5:40pm EDT): Now it's 547 posts. Perhaps it's just me, but they are a helluva lot funnier than Last Comic Standing.
Update 2: There is now a Tuscan Whole Milk website
This is now viral: Amazon watch out for other food products.
Update: (as of 5:40pm EDT): Now it's 547 posts. Perhaps it's just me, but they are a helluva lot funnier than Last Comic Standing.
Update 2: There is now a Tuscan Whole Milk website
This is now viral: Amazon watch out for other food products.
A Judge with a Bad Driving Record
His Honour Brian Galpin
From The Daily Telegraph obituary. More at 8/9/2006
His Honour Brian Galpin, who has died aged 85, was an erudite and eccentric pillar of the Western Circuit.
Tall and imposing, with an unruly shock of hair and bushy eyebrows, he was a sharp lawyer who conformed to the popular image of a judge. In reality he was broad-minded and humane, a firm opponent of capital punishment. In private he was amiable and unassuming, often whimsical and surprisingly unconventional.
Galpin would brook no interruption to the smooth running of his court. Drivers who trespassed on his parking space outside could expect to be hauled before him for a reprimand. After one such incident, while he was sitting at Newport, an outraged correspondent to the Isle of Wight County Press suggested that to stamp one's foot and turn blue with rage when mildly inconvenienced - a ludicrous caricature of the unflappable judge - would normally be regarded as contemptible, unless, apparently, one was "Judge Brian Galpin, whose medieval-style working clothes seem to match his feudal way of life".
When Galpin came unstuck, it was usually to do with motor cars. He was gifted in many fields, but not as a driver. On his way to court at Bodmin, he crashed his Jaguar Mark 10 on a narrow bend, earning a six-month disqualification from the local magistrates for careless driving, with a further six months under the totting-up regulations.
Galpin, by then an aspiring judge, strove for a low-key appeal, hoping that his poor driving record would go unnoticed by both press and Lord Chancellor. However, he was skilfully represented by a colleague who emphasised the poor signage at the scene. This indicated that the road ahead was narrow and twisted, but not that it bent alarmingly at a right angle, suddenly narrowing by a full six feet. The judge agreed that "Road ahead becomes diabolical" would be a more appropriate warning, a phrase eagerly seized upon by the local press. Despite his vindication, Galpin's hopes for minimal publicity were thwarted, the story being treated to a centre-page spread in the Daily Express.
From The Daily Telegraph obituary. More at 8/9/2006
Being Catholic
There is a discussion going on at Andrew Sullivan's Daily Dish blog about whether one can be a merely "cultural" Catholic, or whether belief in certain propositions is necessary. Andrew argues that anyone who can honestly say the Nicene Creed is Catholic enough for him.
There is a problem with this though. All Orthodox and the vast majority of Protestants can also say the Nicene Creed without reservations. That alone does not make one a Catholic.
I agree that an adult Catholic should be able to agree to the propositions in the Creed, but there are problems with this approach to Catholicism.
First, it is probable that the theological meaning of many of the propositions remains obscure to most people. For example, the phrase about God's creation of all things "seen and unseen" refers not to matter and energy, but to his creation of this world and the world of angels. Such underlying meanings are present in almost every phrase. Many people "agree" with the Creed without understanding it.
Second, the idea that "faith" means "agreement to propositions" is primarily an aspect of Calvinist theology. This approach derives from the Reformation analysis that "Credo/I believe" is primarily a matter of intellectual activity. But the Greek word used in the Creed's original form is "pisteo" and means both assent to and trust in. In one way the Creed could be translated as "I trust in One God, the Father Almighty...."
Orthodoxy and Catholicism have always held that faith is as much a matter of trusting in God than asserting propositions - that's why children, catechumens (who did not know the details), and the mentally deficient have always been held to be capable of faith and indeed sainthood.
I would argue that someone who has problems with certain propositions of faith, but whose heart reaches out in poetry and art to trust in God, can be counted as faithful.
Personally I always liked John Betjeman's summary of Christian faith - trusting that
There is a problem with this though. All Orthodox and the vast majority of Protestants can also say the Nicene Creed without reservations. That alone does not make one a Catholic.
I agree that an adult Catholic should be able to agree to the propositions in the Creed, but there are problems with this approach to Catholicism.
First, it is probable that the theological meaning of many of the propositions remains obscure to most people. For example, the phrase about God's creation of all things "seen and unseen" refers not to matter and energy, but to his creation of this world and the world of angels. Such underlying meanings are present in almost every phrase. Many people "agree" with the Creed without understanding it.
Second, the idea that "faith" means "agreement to propositions" is primarily an aspect of Calvinist theology. This approach derives from the Reformation analysis that "Credo/I believe" is primarily a matter of intellectual activity. But the Greek word used in the Creed's original form is "pisteo" and means both assent to and trust in. In one way the Creed could be translated as "I trust in One God, the Father Almighty...."
Orthodoxy and Catholicism have always held that faith is as much a matter of trusting in God than asserting propositions - that's why children, catechumens (who did not know the details), and the mentally deficient have always been held to be capable of faith and indeed sainthood.
I would argue that someone who has problems with certain propositions of faith, but whose heart reaches out in poetry and art to trust in God, can be counted as faithful.
Personally I always liked John Betjeman's summary of Christian faith - trusting that
God was man in Palestine
And lives today in bread and wine.
The Last Tudor Claimant to the British Throne
King Anthony, a former Shropshire police inspector who insisted he had a better claim to the throne than King George V, provoked panic at the palace when two doctors refused to silence him by quietly certifying him insane.
Details have emerged from the National Archive of the royal family's anxiety at the way Anthony Hall, who was said to be tall and always impeccably dressed, drew crowds of up to 800 people to hear his claims of direct lineage from Henry VIII. Across the West Midlands, he used his 1931 campaign meetings to denounce King George, the Queen's grandfather, as a "pure blooded German" with no right to rule Britain.
The Guardian 8/9/2006
Tuesday, August 08, 2006
The Joys of Yiddish
I know I have been posting slowly lately....but this cheered me up.
Wikipedia, The Joys of Yiddish
[See Leo] Rosten's classic riddle — "What's green, hangs on a wall and whistles?" The original version appears in The Joys of Yiddish, where the answer is "A Herring" (as you can paint it green, nail it to the wall and the whistling part is added just to make the riddle hard).
Wikipedia, The Joys of Yiddish
Sunday, August 06, 2006
Gays flee Iraq as Shia death squads find a new target
Evidence shows increase in number of executions as homosexuals plead for asylum in Britain
Hardline Islamic insurgent groups in Iraq are targeting a new type of victim with the full protection of Iraqi law, The Observer can reveal. The country is seeing a sudden escalation of brutal attacks on what are being called the 'immorals' - homosexual men and children as young as 11 who have been forced into same-sex prostitution.
Jennifer Copestake, The Observer 8/6/2006
A couple of points here.
1. Who are the customers? Answer: the large number of men who have homosexual sex before they can get married. It is common throughout the Muslim world.
2. The attacks by religious societal controllers is focused on those who cannot do anything about the situation. Surely noone can morally blame those who are forced into prostitution? The problem for Christians in arguing this is that St. Paul's condemnation of male and female prostitutes in his time focused on a similar group of forced sex-workers. What's good for St. Paul seems good for the Mullahs.
Thursday, August 03, 2006
Catholic and Shia Engagement: Faith and Reason in Theory and Practice.
Now here is a really interesting account of what Shi'ism is all about from a fairly sympathetic Catholic perspective. Note that The Tablet is a British Catholic Magazine.
Anthony O'Mahony, "The rise of Shia," The Tablet 7/29/2006
So who are the Shia? The usual way to describe Shi'ism's essence is to say that its adherents have always championed the claim of Ali, the cousin and son-in-law of Muhammad, to be their prophet's true successor.
They believe that rule over the Muslim community must rest solely with Ali's descendants. Shia is indeed a contraction of Shi'at 'Ali - Ali's faction. After Muhammad's death, Muslims who favoured other candidates repeatedly blocked the accession of Ali to the caliphate. When he finally did come to rule, they withheld their allegiance. Later they crushed his family and followers on a desolate plain in modern Iraq in 680. This event, commemorated annually by Shia though the observance of a period of mourning, provided Shia Islam with a deeply emotive drama of martyrdom.
A line of Ali's descendants, the Imams, were persecuted and allegedly martyred for representing a living challenge to tyrannical rule. It is this sense of suffered injustice that came to pervade Shi'ism. The fate of martyrs was all the more poignant as they had been slain by fellow Muslims. To mourn them was also to grieve for the lost of unity of Islam. Even today, Muslim "ecumenism" remains an intellectual exercise, with almost no place in the intimate dialogue between Shia hierarchy and believers. What began as a dissident position on the matter of succession in the seventh century blossomed in time into a full religious tradition, distinguished from Sunni Islam by its own reading of theology and sacred history.
Anthony O'Mahony, "The rise of Shia," The Tablet 7/29/2006
I hope this is not true
All that is good news for President Ahmadinejad, who claims that Sunni radicalism has reached the limits of its capabilities in the fight against the global system led by the US and that it is now the turn of the Shia, led by Iran, to be in the driving seat.
“Hezbollah has fought Israel longer than all the major Arab armies combined ever did,” President Ahmadinejad told a crowd in Tehran this week. He also promised that Muslims would soon hear “very good news” about the jihad against the United States.
Amir Taheri, "This is just the start of a showdown between the West and The Rest," The Times 8/2/2006
This article is just about the most depressing analysis of the current mess.
Tuesday, August 01, 2006
Will Israel Loose?
I think Israel may well loose this war - anything that looks like a Hezbollah draw is an Israeli loss. That would be a disaster, since Israel's reputation as invincible is an important part of its defense. This must be one dumb administration: I want the US to win in Iraq and Afghanistan, and Israel vs Lebanon, but now "we" are involved are involved in two wars, perhaps three, in which "we" cannot afford to lose, but see no way to win.
See the analysis by Shmuel Rosner in Slate 7/31/2006
See the analysis by Shmuel Rosner in Slate 7/31/2006
Dumb Statistic of the Moment
Apart from a few states on the Pacific Coast and in the mid-Atlantic, Democrats are now a captive party of the Northern Tier. We haven't won an electoral vote in the South so far this century.
Bruce Reed in Slate 8/1/2006
Mel
There's a lot to dislike about Gibson. He is given to furious tirades against homosexuals of the sort that make one wonder if he has some kind of subliminal or "unaddressed" problem. His vulgar and nasty movies, which also feature this prejudice, are additionally replete with the cheapest caricatures of the English. Braveheart and The Patriot are two of the most laughable historical films ever made. (Englishmen don't form picket lines outside movie theaters when "stereotyped," but still.) He has told interviewers that his wife, the mother of his children, is going to hell because she subscribes to the wrong Christian sect (a view that he justifies as "a pronouncement from the chair"). And it has been obvious for some time to the most meager intelligence that he is sick to his empty core with Jew-hatred.
Christopher Hitchens, Slate 8/1/2006
Ham and High
I used to live in Hampstead before I moved to the United States (19 years ago this week). This local story (from the Hampstead and Highgate Express 7/28/2006 on reactions to a current tabloid press scandal surrounding George Michael is truly amazing. Britain has become another country from the one I left.
What is really of is that the various voices quoted are all being very tolerant and accepting but cannot bring themselves to say "used condoms." That is very British.
What is really of is that the various voices quoted are all being very tolerant and accepting but cannot bring themselves to say "used condoms." That is very British.
Support for George Michael's defence of cruising on Heath
28 July 2006
LOCAL groups have come out in defence of gay cruising on Hampstead Heath - but want visitors to pick up their condoms.
They have spoken out after pop legend George Michael defended an encounter with a middle-aged stranger at London's notorious gay hotspot.
The former Wham frontman laughed off the rendezvous with a 58-year-old van driver, who he compared to fat comedian Bernard Manning.
The 43-year-old, who lives in Highgate, said: "Sorry if people don't like the fact I cruise on Hampstead Heath but the police absolutely accept that it goes on at night. I'm not ashamed of it.
"It's the only place in London where that is the case - so it's generally a safe place.
The gay cruising scene centres on West Heath, which covers about 70 acres of the 800 acre-park.
Tony Hillier, chairman of the Heath and Hampstead Society, said: "Gay cruising on the Heath is the subject of international gay tourist websites. It's very popular. If this sort of thing is going to go on at night, it probably doesn't disturb the average Hampstead resident. But what does is the absolutely filthy mess left behind.
"Dog walkers, people with children shouldn't have to worry about what they are going to find behind the next bush."
He added that the society was part of the "very enlightened" Sexual Activities Working Group on the Heath and, rather like the successful campaign to get dog owners to pick up their pet's mess, the group was working to train gay cruisers to clean up their litter too.
He added: "The current budget for clearing up the mess, which is frankly disgusting, is £80,000 a year.
"They just have to be reminded there's a lot of other people who use the Heath."
The Camden's Lesbian Gay Bisexual and Transgender Forum said: "There needs to be a clear public acknowledgement that the reasons many engage in public sexual activity are complex - in many cases reflecting personal experiences of homophobia. They need to be supported by police with a view to their own safety."
But visitors to the Heath were split on the subject of cruising.
Richard Hudson, 30, a nurse from Birmingham, said: "It's famous this place for it. Why not just let them get on with it? It's not illegal, is it?"
But Nathalie Benjamin, 17, said: "It's sort of obscene. At any time of day it's just wrong."
At times the Heath has proven to be a very dangerous place for cruisers. Several years ago, a notorious violent robber, known as Gold Tooth, targeted gay men visiting the Heath.
Richard Gentry, manager of the Heath Constabulary, said they patrolled the perimeter of West Heath.
He said: "We don't condone the activity and are working very closely with organisations such as the Terrence Higgins Trust, trying to get the message across about people taking their litter home. Anyone acting inappropriately will be dealt with."
Sunday, July 30, 2006
The Longue Duree in the United States
New research from around the world has begun to reveal a picture of humans today that is so different from what it was in the past that scientists say they are startled. Over the past 100 years, says one researcher, Robert W. Fogel of the University of Chicago, humans in the industrialized world have undergone a form of evolution that is unique not only to humankind, but unique among the 7,000 or so generations of humans who have ever inhabited the earth.
The difference does not involve changes in genes, as far as is known, but changes in the human form. It shows up in several ways, from those that are well known and almost taken for granted, like greater heights and longer lives, to ones that are emerging only from comparisons of health records.
The biggest surprise emerging from the new studies is that many chronic ailments like heart disease, lung disease and arthritis are occurring an average of 10 to 25 years later than they used to. There is also less disability among older people today, according to a federal study that directly measures it. And that is not just because medical treatments like cataract surgery keep people functioning. Human bodies are simply not breaking down the way they did before.
GINA KOLATA, So Big and Healthy Grandpa Wouldn't Even Know You, New York Times 7/28/206
It is a little strange that this fascinating article is written by a health/science reporter. Scientific and health measurements form the basis of the facts in this article, but it is about much more than science.
History is often seen as analyzing events, but for forty years now, historians have been interested in social phenomena that remain the same or change very slowly. This longue duree [long duration] addresses the sorts of issues raised in the NY Times' article, and claims that such transitions are needed to understand the past as the much more studied "changes."
Saturday, July 29, 2006
Evangelicals and the Religious Right
Anyone who knows about the work of Jim Wallace and Sojourner magazine, or reflects on the Reverend Martin Luther King's work, knows that Evangelicalism has never been as attached to the Right in politics as it is today.
This New York Times story Disowning Conservative Politics Is Costly for Evangelical Pastor, 7/29/2006, is very interesting indeed.
This New York Times story Disowning Conservative Politics Is Costly for Evangelical Pastor, 7/29/2006, is very interesting indeed.
“When the church wins the culture wars, it inevitably loses,” Mr. Boyd preached. “When it conquers the world, it becomes the world. When you put your trust in the sword, you lose the cross.”
Friday, July 28, 2006
Gay Existence
Of interest in this context is Professor Oliver O'Donovan's essay on the crisis facing liberalism, posted on the Fulcrum website. Prof O'Donovan is about to leave Oxford and go to Edinburgh. His essay includes this passage: "Gays also pose existential questions. They interest themselves in the riddle of gay existence. Anexetastos bios abiôtos, said Socrates; the life that is unexamined is intolerable to live. And much of the gay Angst is to do with the difficulty of raising questions in public that seem overwhelmingly pressing when they directly concern oneself. The pastoral challenge that the gay phenomenon presents to the church, then, is not primarily emancipatory, but hermeneutic. And that is the supreme justification for a conciliar process that will take up the experience of homosexual Christians as its leading question. How is this form of feeling to be understood? What are the patterns of life with which it may appropriately clothe itself? As far as I can tell, it is deeply in the interest of gay Christians, men and women, that their experience - by which is meant not merely sexual experience, not merely emotional experience, and not merely the narrative of experience, but the whole storehouse of what they have felt and thought about their lives, should become a matter of wider reflection, reflected on by those who are called to live this experience, by those who are called to accompany them in their living, by all who share their understanding of living as something they owe an account of to God."
Apologies for pushing The Times, here 7/27/2006 but Ruth Gledhill's blog there, Articles of Faith, is outstanding. [She is The Times religion reporter.]
Post-Christian Britain
There are now more black churchgoers in London than white and the black-led churches such as KICC are bursting at the seams.
Ruth Gledhill, The Times, 7/27/2006
What Are Academics For?
An article by Mary Beard, of Cambridge University, in the Times Online 7/18/2006
Thursday, July 27, 2006
A Byzantine Document in the News
The manuscript in question is a 13th century prayerbook that is also, as a palimpsest, the oldest surviving manuscript of Archimedes.
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5583668
I have to say that, as a Byzantinist, I find the dismissal of the Byzantine context of the manuscript somewhat annoying.
The manuscript is in the Walter's Art Museum in Baltimore (a truly wonderful place). It has its own website at http://www.archimedespalimpsest.org/
http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5583668
I have to say that, as a Byzantinist, I find the dismissal of the Byzantine context of the manuscript somewhat annoying.
The manuscript is in the Walter's Art Museum in Baltimore (a truly wonderful place). It has its own website at http://www.archimedespalimpsest.org/
Trey in China
One of the links on the right of this page is to Treyopia. Trey is a former student of mine who is teaching in China. The blog is really an account of his experiences there. It's really good, and should inspire those who have not yet traveled to "get on yer bike."
After you get back, you forget all the diarrhea, people spitting on trains, fear of being so afr from home. After you get back, you look at the people around you and wonder how they get get by without knowing there is a world to see.
After you get back, you forget all the diarrhea, people spitting on trains, fear of being so afr from home. After you get back, you look at the people around you and wonder how they get get by without knowing there is a world to see.
The Last Ottoman
Ertugrul Osman is the current head of the Ottoman dynasty. The Ottomans ruled much of the middle east from c.1299 until 1922. They were regarded with horror by muhc of Europe, but to an increasing number of people, the Ottoman period in the middle east looks increasingly benign. Compared to the disaster of ethnic and religious conflict it seems positively benificient.
It turns out the current heir lives in New York City (New York Times, 3/26/2006) in a Lexington Avenue apartment. And he has a Jewish landlord.
The world is an interesting place indeed.
It turns out the current heir lives in New York City (New York Times, 3/26/2006) in a Lexington Avenue apartment. And he has a Jewish landlord.
The world is an interesting place indeed.
The Israel-Hezbollah War: Who is to Blame?
And Some People Think Jacksonville is a Small Town
"When Applebee's opened here, people really thought Jamestown was finally on the map," says Robert Carlson, president of the Farmers Union and a Jamestown resident.
Time 7/27/2006
Wednesday, July 26, 2006
History Questions 7/26/2006
This blog is linked to from the Internet History Sourcebooks Project. If you have come here with some question, ask it as a "reply to the this post (which will be reposted every few days).
Wikipedia on the 750th Anniversary of the US
..according to the The Onion
The Onion 7/26/2006
I love Wikipedia, but a friend tipped me off on this.
The entry also addresses several traditionally taboo subjects, such as the influence of LSD on the drafting of the Constitution and the role of funk-slaves in painting the White House black.
The Onion 7/26/2006
I love Wikipedia, but a friend tipped me off on this.
Gay Marriage today
There was a second consecutive state supreme court decision against same-sex marriage today (in Washington state), but this is a less a disaster than it might seem. Many years ago Andrew Sullivan argued that this policy would advance through a mix of methods, and in a patchwork pattern. He is turning out to be right. Court decisions certainly paved the way in both Canada and the US. Those court decisions have undercut any argument that gay marriage is destroying society: no such thing has happened as gay couples have proved to be just as boring (or exciting) as straight couples.
Legislatures now have some room to work - hence Connecticut created Civil Union laws, and California has come down in favor of equality for gay marriage. Now individual politicians running for state wide office are using the issue as an argument to vote for them.
Elliott Spitzer, almost certainly next governor of New York State http://time.blogs.com/daily_dish/2006/07/Washington's_cou.html
Spitzer, almost certainly, will run for president at some date, but he is not hedging his bets in any way.
As long as it exists in only one state, gay marriage remains in some danger. Once you get eight or more states where it is recognized, then the game is over. My guess for the first eight states: Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, California, Rhode Island, Oregon and, perhaps, Illinois. Wht Illinois, even though half the state is in the South? Because that state was the first to legalize homosexual behaviour (in 1961), and because it contains a world city.
World cities have been at the forefront of celebrating gay people. And world cities enjoy being world cities. The more anti-gay legislation is seen as unclassy and small minded, the more it will be disputed.
[In the UK, all the rights of marriage have been extended to gay people via "civil partnerships." I guess Britain will probably continue to use this old fashioned language for longer than necessary, even as the population just uses "wed/married/hitched", and then all of a sudden in a burst of modernization will adopt the term "marriage" as a form of tidying up.
It is hard to express why this issue is so important. It is not really about hospital visits or social acceptance (many/most hospitals have accepted same-sex partners of patients for quite some time now), but of the impact of the creation of a widely know legal formualary for gay relationships on younger people who are just recognizing themselves. When you know that there is a state performed gay union rite, you will not ever feel as you grow up that you are alone. It is due to an obligation to those who will come after us that gay people, and not just activists, have come to see this issue as crucial.]
Legislatures now have some room to work - hence Connecticut created Civil Union laws, and California has come down in favor of equality for gay marriage. Now individual politicians running for state wide office are using the issue as an argument to vote for them.
"I think same sex marriage should be legal. I will propose a bill to permit that to be the case in the state of New York."
Elliott Spitzer, almost certainly next governor of New York State http://time.blogs.com/daily_dish/2006/07/Washington's_cou.html
Spitzer, almost certainly, will run for president at some date, but he is not hedging his bets in any way.
As long as it exists in only one state, gay marriage remains in some danger. Once you get eight or more states where it is recognized, then the game is over. My guess for the first eight states: Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut, California, Rhode Island, Oregon and, perhaps, Illinois. Wht Illinois, even though half the state is in the South? Because that state was the first to legalize homosexual behaviour (in 1961), and because it contains a world city.
World cities have been at the forefront of celebrating gay people. And world cities enjoy being world cities. The more anti-gay legislation is seen as unclassy and small minded, the more it will be disputed.
[In the UK, all the rights of marriage have been extended to gay people via "civil partnerships." I guess Britain will probably continue to use this old fashioned language for longer than necessary, even as the population just uses "wed/married/hitched", and then all of a sudden in a burst of modernization will adopt the term "marriage" as a form of tidying up.
It is hard to express why this issue is so important. It is not really about hospital visits or social acceptance (many/most hospitals have accepted same-sex partners of patients for quite some time now), but of the impact of the creation of a widely know legal formualary for gay relationships on younger people who are just recognizing themselves. When you know that there is a state performed gay union rite, you will not ever feel as you grow up that you are alone. It is due to an obligation to those who will come after us that gay people, and not just activists, have come to see this issue as crucial.]
The Queen has to look like the Queen.

"There are all sorts of considerations about what she wears that the rest of us don't have to worry about," says Penny Junor, the royal biographer. "She can't wear skirts that are going to fly over her head if there is a gust of wind, or hats that are going to shield her face, because she has to be visible. Decorum is a big consideration, she could never have low-fronts, she always has to be model perfect."
Her choice of bright, pastel colours might not always be of the moment, but they enable fans and press cameras to pick her out in the midst of large crowds. Because the Queen has to look like the Queen.
A defense of Her Majesty's fashion sense in a very unlikely place, Scotland's newspaper The Scotsman, 7/26/2006
Tuesday, July 25, 2006
Shakespeare does the G8
Giorgio: But good Antonio, take we counsel now concerning the Levant.
My lord Annan, charged by the nations in their assembly to calm the noise of war,
Seeks only to separate the arms, thinking thereby to fulfil the task.
But the enmerded Moor, taking this peace for respite and repose,
By my vision, readies his galleys for renewed assault on the enrag’d Jew.
The Times, July 25th
"Enmerded Moor"?
Gay People to Blame for Hezbollah Attacks
As I've mentioned before, the business of opposing a planned Gay Pride march in Jerusalem is one of the few topics which generate widespread agreement between religious groups in that city, groups which are otherwise generally at each others' throats. The imams never wanted the march; both the Orthodox and the Catholic clergy didn't either; nor most of the rabbis. Indeed one rabbi saw the Hezbollah attacks on Israel as a direct consequence of the planned parade.
James Collard, The Times July 24
The "World Pride" festival was scheduled to take place in Jerusalem in August. All the religious groups opposed it.
Brits in America
To be honest, I think my whole mood, even my view of life struck the wrong note here. Americans cherish a self-image of themselves as casual, lively and free and the English as reserved, even stuck-up. But sometimes the opposite is true and I'd get in to trouble for swearing, for example, or making a frivolous remark about the task in hand ("well, it's only words and pictures!") to lighten the mood, none of which tends to go down well here. To use broad brush-strokes, I'd say that Americans are more serious, less flip; then again, they can seem more determined than Brits, less cynical. These are our different national virtues.
And with gay culture here, very often the mood of seriousness - and a readiness for anger which I found truly shocking - comes from entirely understandable sources. Gay America was hit harder by AIDS, for example, while the Religious Right is a serious opponent. In Britain, one senses that despite setbacks, gay people pushing for equality are pushing against a door which opens ever wider with every year. In America, there is an equally energetic, often more powerful lobby pushing back from the other side. So ever apparent step forward - like a State moving to endorse gay marriage (and gay marriage is a particularly sore subject in this city right now) results in a backlash, with a highly motivated, politically organised Christian right lobbying for constitutional changes or redress through higher courts.
James Collard, The Times, Jul 14 2006
I largely agree with his comments. British people think America is like Britain (and vice-versa). But it's not. America is a very foreign country. This is good in some ways (the relative lack of class consciousness, the divideness of government), but severely awful in others (the lack of vacation time, the avoidance of real class conflict, the willingness to deny government interference in life combined with allowing massive private enterprise control and intrusion).
Monday, July 24, 2006
It's getting hotter
The question of why there aren't viable alternative energy options (particularly when the electric car was not only more popular than the gasoline engine once upon a time but was also shown as recently as ten years ago to be a working technology) is raised subtly by An Inconvenient Truth. The rest of it--the pictures of glaciers shrinking into nothing, the graphs demonstrating the massive increase in greenhouse gasses in the last few decades--ties in cozily with the sudden hurricane-destruction of New Orleans and the evacuation of a lot of Pennsylvania due to fears of flooding. You're alarmed by it only if you don't think that, to crib from "The Daily Show", Adam and Eve rode a brontosaurus to church and, perhaps more divisively and to the point, that evolution is a theory and that two men who want to get married spells moral and spiritual Armageddon more neatly than does invading a Muslim country for their oil.
Film Freak: Review of An Inconvenient Truth.
Do it like Zidane
ZIDANE a new way to solve problems.. do it like zidane...
OK,I wrote during the World Cup, so I can cite this clip.
YouTube is about to jump the shark.
OK,I wrote during the World Cup, so I can cite this clip.
YouTube is about to jump the shark.
The War in the Levant
In my opinion, this is becoming PR disaster for Israel.
The Lebanese do not look like raving maniacs, and I don't think Israel has had a war before where the opposing country comes over so well. Lebanon is not like other Arab countries. The Lebanese do not look like women-oppressing Saudis, or enraged barbaric Palestinians, or a raving Shi'te mob. They look like us: they look like people in Miami living under shelling. Hell, many of them are Christian, perhaps 40%.
Some IM correspondents have asked me about my opinion. Here it is.
I support Israel. I think both the West and the Islamic World owe Jews an immense apology for the way (worse in the West) both civilizations treated Jews. I think anti-Semitism in the Arab world is disgusting. And I think, as a gay man, Israel is the only country in the Middle East (outside Turkey) I could live in. And if it comes down to it, I am on the Israeli side.
But, I will not count an Arab life (Chistian or Muslim) as less than a Jewish or "American" life.
I have indeed noticed that there is a helluva lot of PR going around me. [We have 350+ dead on both sides after 12 days. Damned, more people have died from driving accidents in Israel in this period. More people died in the first 30 seconds of the Somme in 1916.]
This is a skirmish in the wider scheme of things. I think people suggesting the thesis that were are beginning WWIII have jumped the shark. I could be wrong, but...(See if I am wrong).
As of 7/24/2006 WWIII is not on the the radar. Israel has had an effect on Hezbollah, and will exercise a suppressive effect via land forces in the next 4 days. It has perhaps fivemore days to do this.
Condeleeza Rice's presence from Sunday in the he middle east will mean a smaller war and growing pressure because the western media are refusing to reduce the Lebanese people to the animality. [I could be very wrong here.] Many of us have, as well as Jewish, Lebanese friends and colleagues.
Both sides seem to have miscalculated to a massive extent. Hezbollah did not expect Israel to fight back (as it has a right to do); but Israel did not realize the impact it is making in the US with continual raids on a modern city.
[And, since we are all racist, the world has just ignored Darfur, AND the coming Somali-Ethiopian War, AND the Tsunami in Java.]
The Lebanese do not look like raving maniacs, and I don't think Israel has had a war before where the opposing country comes over so well. Lebanon is not like other Arab countries. The Lebanese do not look like women-oppressing Saudis, or enraged barbaric Palestinians, or a raving Shi'te mob. They look like us: they look like people in Miami living under shelling. Hell, many of them are Christian, perhaps 40%.
Some IM correspondents have asked me about my opinion. Here it is.
I support Israel. I think both the West and the Islamic World owe Jews an immense apology for the way (worse in the West) both civilizations treated Jews. I think anti-Semitism in the Arab world is disgusting. And I think, as a gay man, Israel is the only country in the Middle East (outside Turkey) I could live in. And if it comes down to it, I am on the Israeli side.
But, I will not count an Arab life (Chistian or Muslim) as less than a Jewish or "American" life.
I have indeed noticed that there is a helluva lot of PR going around me. [We have 350+ dead on both sides after 12 days. Damned, more people have died from driving accidents in Israel in this period. More people died in the first 30 seconds of the Somme in 1916.]
This is a skirmish in the wider scheme of things. I think people suggesting the thesis that were are beginning WWIII have jumped the shark. I could be wrong, but...(See if I am wrong).
[And, since we are all racist, the world has just ignored Darfur, AND the coming Somali-Ethiopian War, AND the Tsunami in Java.]
Conservatives and Me
It's odd but true that, since I moved to the US South, most of my best friends, and in recent years, greatest supporters, are self-labeled "conservatives."
I find many of the people who position themselves on the "left" to be either rabid or incoherent. Indeed for a British Democratic Socialist, modern US progressives are hard to deal with: we often share political positions, but a "left" without the working class is very odd.
The problem is, as was shown when I made an overly emotional post on gay marriage, is that in a real way there are some basic issues where it's hard for me to comprehend how someone can be friendly with me, but still see me as some kind of inferior being, and where the only kind of relationships I could form that would bring happiness, are seen as evil.
On the other hand, I suppose that with those conservatives who befriend me (suddenly I sound like a wet puppy), homosexuality is not a primary issue. They are pissed off at what they see as a nanny state, and, in economic terms, focus on the virtues of self-reliance and oppose a dependency culture. (I have met very few people, of any group, who think the War on Drugs makes any sense. Even as they [and I] acknowledge what ruin drugs can bring on individuals.)
I suppose that this will remain a conundrum.
I find many of the people who position themselves on the "left" to be either rabid or incoherent. Indeed for a British Democratic Socialist, modern US progressives are hard to deal with: we often share political positions, but a "left" without the working class is very odd.
The problem is, as was shown when I made an overly emotional post on gay marriage, is that in a real way there are some basic issues where it's hard for me to comprehend how someone can be friendly with me, but still see me as some kind of inferior being, and where the only kind of relationships I could form that would bring happiness, are seen as evil.
On the other hand, I suppose that with those conservatives who befriend me (suddenly I sound like a wet puppy), homosexuality is not a primary issue. They are pissed off at what they see as a nanny state, and, in economic terms, focus on the virtues of self-reliance and oppose a dependency culture. (I have met very few people, of any group, who think the War on Drugs makes any sense. Even as they [and I] acknowledge what ruin drugs can bring on individuals.)
I suppose that this will remain a conundrum.
WKCR in New York : Homosexuality in History
I was interviewed today by Shoshana Schwartz of WKCR (Columbia University Radio) in New York. The subject was attituded to homosexuality in Ancient Greece, in comparison with other ancient cultures and modern culture.
The interview will air as a segment of a program called Late City Edition, and will first air on Tuesday 25th July between 9 and 9:30pm.
On the air, if you are in the New York area, the frequency is 89.9 FM. You can listen on the internet at www.wkcr.org.
UPDATE: the interview air on July 25th for around 15 minutes. The interviewer had somewhat odd voice (a bit like Diane Rehm on NPR). The interview should be archived at www.wkcr.org under archives>news>Late City Edition 7/25/2006, but it's not there yet.
The interview will air as a segment of a program called Late City Edition, and will first air on Tuesday 25th July between 9 and 9:30pm.
On the air, if you are in the New York area, the frequency is 89.9 FM. You can listen on the internet at www.wkcr.org.
UPDATE: the interview air on July 25th for around 15 minutes. The interviewer had somewhat odd voice (a bit like Diane Rehm on NPR). The interview should be archived at www.wkcr.org under archives>news>Late City Edition 7/25/2006, but it's not there yet.
God, guns, and gays

See also Rudy Giuliani in Drag Smooching Donald Trump at YouTube.
Newsweek's Eleanor Clift had plenty of company when she contemplated Hurricane Katrina's devastation and asked, "Where is Rudy Giuliani when we need him?" In the political-leadership sweepstakes, Giuliani is A-number-one, top of the list, king of the hill. But Sinatra's catchy claim is turned on its head in the presidential sweepstakes: When it comes to winning over GOP primary voters, if you can make it in New York, you can't make it anywhere else.
God, guns, and gays. An interesting article by Kate O'Beirne in the National Review on why Rudy Giuliani cannot get the Republican nomination for President.
It does soometimes look as if political conservatism (as opposed to ideological conservatism) has come down to these issues among many American men. I think Giuliani would be an awful president, and articles written at the time of his New York mayoral runs in the New Yorker about his past would almost certainly sink him.
The National Review highlights the article on its cover with a picture of Rudy Giuliani dressed up as Marilyn Monroe. This image was quite well known in New York. It was from a fundraising party in which Giuliani ordered all his top staff to cross dress, and then himself dressed as Marilyn, and sang "Happy Birthday, Mr. President." At the time, Drag bars in New York put "Thank You Mr Mayor" posters in their windows.
But O'Beirne is an old bird. I wonder if all this will make any difference. The "god, guns, and gays" issue seem to me to be as much about male self image than anything else. Many men simply use these issues as markers for the WIMP (Woefully I Inadequate Male Person) issue. But, whatever his faults, and no matter how much you dislike him, noone could regard Giliani as a WIMP.
After all, it takes a strong man to wear a dress.
{update: Andrew Sullivan discusses the New Republics covere here
Sunday, July 23, 2006
Looks Like a New Saint's Cult to Me
My dissertation was, in part, an exploration of the "contestation" that took place during the creation of new saints.
Follow this report on "Fr. Mark" of the Punjab: BBC, 23 July 2006.
That he "fought" Church leaders is a trope of sanctity.
Follow this report on "Fr. Mark" of the Punjab: BBC, 23 July 2006.
That he "fought" Church leaders is a trope of sanctity.
Friday, July 21, 2006
Shi'ism and the News
Rememember Nixon!
That's my motto in watching news coverage of any event. The Daily Telegraph is, by far, the most Conservative British newspaper. It is also very pro-Israel. But the British upper-middle class British values a much wider divergence of opinion than exists in the US. That is where to look for angles you may not have thought of.
Here is an very informative view on the Shia-Sunni conflict from today's Telegraph.
That's my motto in watching news coverage of any event. The Daily Telegraph is, by far, the most Conservative British newspaper. It is also very pro-Israel. But the British upper-middle class British values a much wider divergence of opinion than exists in the US. That is where to look for angles you may not have thought of.
Here is an very informative view on the Shia-Sunni conflict from today's Telegraph.
Rats....
Exiled radical Islamic preacher Omar Bakri was turned away from a Royal Navy ship evacuating Britons from war-torn Beirut, it emerged today.
The Muslim cleric, who left Britain for Lebanon abruptly in August last year, tried to board the British ship yesterday. He also claimed he had written to the British embassy asking to be allowed to back on "humanitarian grounds".
The Guardian, today.
There is a Yiddish word for what this guy has: Chutzpah. [Defined by example by Leo Rosten in The Joys of Yiddish. A man kills both his parents: he pleads to the judge for mercy on the grounds he is an orphan.]
This does not seem the time....
...for Israel to be commemorating a famous terrorist act against the British Mandate government in Palestine. Sixty years ago the Irgun Zvi Leumi blew up a wing of the King David Hotel in Jerusalem. 91 people were killed. Now there is a celebration.
At a time when, unlike French or Russian leader, Britain's Prime Minister is vocally supporting Israel, this seems a little strange.
At a time when, unlike French or Russian leader, Britain's Prime Minister is vocally supporting Israel, this seems a little strange.
Oh My G-d
This is what America is watching!
http://youtube.com/watch?v=UygWaEDfKJ8
Don't be upset. Brits made "Run Rabbit, Run, Run, Run" a hit in WW II.
Update:
At Slate
http://youtube.com/watch?v=UygWaEDfKJ8
Don't be upset. Brits made "Run Rabbit, Run, Run, Run" a hit in WW II.
Update:
At Slate
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)